They're Made Out Of Meat

Channel:Stephen O'Regan · Length:7:24 · Published:2019-09-06 · Views:254409

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 2004 short film adaptation of Terry Bisson's story "They're Made Out of Meat", in which aliens discuss the astonishing discovery of meat-based intelligent life. It stars Tom Noonan and Ben Bailey.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as the best filmed version of the story whenever aliens or the nature of intelligence come up.

O'Reagan's short is the best take on it. — HN, 2023

Stand-up & sketch comedy · Film & TV clips · Literature & writing craft

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] they are made out of meat meat there's no doubt about it we picked up several from different parts of the planet took them aboard our recon vessels and probe them all the way through they are completely meat it's impossible what about the radio signals they use radio signals to talk but the signals don't come from then the signals come from machines well who made the machines that's what we need to contact meat made the machines it's ridiculous we can't make machines these creatures are the only sentient race in this sector and they're made out of meat maybe they're like the or fly a carbon-based intelligence that goes through a meat stage they are born meat and they die meat we studied them for several of their lifespans spare me but maybe they're like the Weddell I only part meat we thought of that since they do have meat heads like the Weddell eye but as I told you we probed them no brain Hey oh there's a brain all right it's just that the brain is made out of meat what does the thinking then the brain does the thinking the meat boys oh my god you're serious they're made out of meat and they've been trying to contact us for almost 100 of their years so what does this meat have in mind first it wants to talk

On Hacker News

I always liked the idea and think O'Reagan's short is the best take on it. A black and white version set in Les Deux Magots, Sartre and Beauvoir at a table in the background, would be nice. [LINK] [VIDEO] — Borrible, 2023-05
Great short film version: [VIDEO] I do wonder sometimes if someone out there is waiting for something actually intelligent to emerge down here. — api, 2026-04
I like that the bearded one can't help cracking up when he says "the ones you probed": [VIDEO] — amiga386, 2026-04
> and many of them have no particular reason to be visible at astronomical distances. Or to want to talk to meat. [VIDEO] — rbanffy, 2026-02

Related videos