Does Hot Water Freeze Faster Than Cold Water?

Channel:Sciencium · Length:7:38 · Published:2017-02-08 · Views:4996713

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sciencium examines the Mpemba effect, the claim that hot water freezes faster than cold water. It walks through experiments and a published paper questioning the effect.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as a concise rundown of why the Mpemba effect likely does not hold up.

walking through all the experiments that demonstrate the effect does not in fact exist. — HN, 2022

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos

Subtitles (excerpt)

does hot water freeze faster than cold water the obvious answer seems to be no because all else being equal the hot water first has to cool down to the same temperature as the cold water and then do everything the cold water has to do in order to freeze so it must take longer right well not according to the impemba effect this effect is named after araso impemba who in 1963 was a Tanzanian student making ice cream as a school project the students were meant to boil a mixture of cream and sugar and then let it cool down before putting it into the freezer but worried about not getting a spot and Pemba put his mixture into the freezer immediately after boiling it and returning an hour and a half later he found that his mixture had Frozen while his classmates had not and Pemba was intrigued by this phenomenon and eventually Enlisted the help of a physics Professor Dennis Osborne to investigate the effect using cream and also water now they managed to replicate impa's finding and published a physics paper stating that warm water does indeed freeze faster than cold but impemba was not the first person to observe this effect it dates back at least to Aristotle who noted the fact that the water has previously

On Hacker News

It's because you was wrong (or at least not correct). The Mpemba Effect wasn't scientifically proven, and can be explained away with error in measurement. [VIDEO] — chotmat, 2026-03
There was a video by Derek/Veritasium as few years ago explaining this and also walking through all the experiments that demonstrate the effect does not in fact exist. [VIDEO] — simonjgreen, 2022-06
We all get the Mpemba effect is totally fake right? You all own freezers so you can test it for yourself, it was found by a child making icecream so it will be easy! And if you're the !first! to put it on Youtube that'd be cool. Sciencium talks about it here if you want an ok run down and how it's not real - [VIDEO] — aaron695, 2020-08

Related videos