Fight Club - The Recall Coordinator's Formula

Channel:Montag Beeblebrox · Length:1:33 · Published:2009-12-29 · Views:252382

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A two-minute clip from the film Fight Club in which the narrator, a former recall coordinator, explains the formula companies use to decide whether a recall costs more than paying out settlements.

Why HN recommends it

Cited whenever a thread shows a company weighing cost against safety or customer harm.

I'm reminded of the delightful opening scene of "Fight Club" where the narrator explains that his job is to apply "The Formula". — HN, 2022

Business & economics (other) · Film & TV clips

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] Not sure you understand how "The Formula" works. The profit generated by adding this feature will outweigh the cost of any resulting accidents that they take liability for. A less pessimistic way of phrasing it is that within the boundaries they've defined, their self driving system is so much better than a human that they're willing to assume responsibility for crashes deemed "at-fault" … — hcazz, 2026-01
> Take the number of vehicles in the field, A, multiply it by the probable rate of failure, B, then multiply it by the result of the average out of court settlement, C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one. [VIDEO] — collingreen, 2025-11
None of this is true. A company left to their own devices will optimize for maximum profit at the cost of literally everything else. Every cost of their business that's possible to externalize will be externalized. Every corner will be cut in the name of marginally better profits. For example, you say lawsuits are costly. To a company, that's meaningless. The only question is, is the cost of a la… — Mawr, 2025-11
>Other manufacturers treat defects in their products by doing a recall and wearing the costs of their mistake. No. Other manufacturers treat defects with recalls after analyzing the fiscal prospect of doing so, and determining whether or not state/regional laws require them to do it. Here's one of the "not that wrong" scenes from Fight Club to better explain[0]. [0]: [VIDEO] — serf, 2025-08
It's kinda insane that they can't do a "undo last commit; git push; tell the CI/CD to push a new OS release" procedure. But there's a probably Fight-Club-esque math (1) there that make it "If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one.". Congrats Google, your procedures have made you an overweight gorilla that isn't agile enough... (1) [VIDEO] — netsharc, 2025-01

Related videos