Forensic Science: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

Channel:LastWeekTonight · Length:18:51 · Published:2017-10-02 · Views:10556805

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A John Oliver Last Week Tonight segment on how forensic science used in criminal trials is often unscientific. It looks at unreliable methods and lab malpractice, and ends with a joke about a TV procedural that might change public perception.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as a light-hearted but informative overview whenever threads touch on junk science and unreliable forensic evidence in courts.

For a light hearted break down of such failures see this — HN, 2019

Law, policing & justice · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

JOHN OLIVER: Crime. You know that thing that was almost solved -by a flasher dog in 1980's. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) But specifically this story is about how we increasingly solve crimes using forensic evidence. It's that thing that is just a staple of TV crime shows. Pull it from the torso on the left. Pull it from the boat on the right. Two hearts beat as one. Matches up perfectly. -(DISTORTED SOUND) -That's a match. -(COMPUTER BEEPS) -MAN 1: We've got a match. MAN 2: And it just found us a match. WOMAN 1: Visible match. -WOMAN 2: We've a match. -Match. MAN 3: Were you able to determine which monkey bit him? The bite marks match those of the monkey found at the scene. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -Wow! That last one was presumably from one of the crossover episodes where the team from Law & Order, worked a case with the cast of Monkey Law and Monkey Order. -(AUDIENCE LAUGHING) -(MONKEY SCREECHES) -But... -(AUDIENCE APPLAUDING) on TV and in real life forensic science plays an important role in criminal convictions. Prosecutors often complain about a so called C.S.I. effect, where jurors expect to see forensic evidence in every case. The problem is, not all forensic science is as reliable as we've become accustomed to believe.

On Hacker News

> Prisoners are deprived of rights... by due process... Nice sound bite; but not really true. It's certainly true a process is followed but that process is pretty shitty. Plenty of people get released after the murder weapon is actually tried for fingerprints and low-and-behold it was somebody else! How does a person go through trial with even the murder weapon being tested? It's not required by … — lesuorac, 2024-01
Not sure if this is what you meant, but Norm's conclusion, > how in good conscience could he act on basically "taking the word of some guy in a white lab coat." is actually quite correct. There is science behind DNA evidence, but there is also frequent malpractice of lab technicians, which ends up muddling results, with life ruining consequences. John Oliver has talked about it: [VIDEO] — rmellow, 2023-11
Related video of Last Week Tonight on different kinds of junk science: [VIDEO] There does seem to be some issues with how the court system has failed to keep up with the modern day. Issues with scalability, accessibility and science literacy are leading to a general distrust of the system. — plopz, 2020-02
And fingerprints, DNA, and eyewitness testimony has all lead to people being wrongly convicted. EDIT: Pasted wrong link first time - sorry [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] For a light hearted break down of such failures see this [VIDEO] To answer your question, I would feel better with multiple forms of evidence as a collective instead of a single piece. EDIT: Also I'm not saying that this guy isn't cheating… — Crosseye_Jack, 2019-10
> Maybe ultimately no one will believe video any more? People believe whatever they want to believe; forensic hair analysis (not DNA) is also quite a controversial practice, it's still accepted as evidence by many courts in the US. Last Week Tonight had a bit about that issue in a recent episode [0] It's sad and mindblowing that people have been sentenced to prison/death because a so-called "expe… — freeflight, 2017-10

Related videos