Are We There Yet - Rich Hickey

Channel:Zhang Jian · Length:1:10:05 · Published:2019-07-29 · Views:24657

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Rich Hickey's talk on time, state, identity and values, arguing that mutable object-oriented modeling fits the world poorly. It lays out the thinking behind Clojure's approach to data and change.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as one of the best explanations of why Clojure and a functional, immutable approach to state exist.

One of the best "why Clojure" talks that I've seen — HN, 2021

Functional programming · Software architecture & design

Subtitles (excerpt)

so I'm gonna talk about time today how we treat time in object-oriented languages generally and and maybe how we how we fail to so I'm trying to provoke you today to just reconsider some fundamental things that I I just think we get so entrenched with what we do every day we fail to step back and look at what exactly are we doing so are we being well served by object orientation as commonly embodied right the concept is pretty broad and there are multiple possible embodiments but the ones that we have have a lot of consistent attributes do we all agree this is the best way to write software so we think this will continue to be the best way certainly today this is a really entrenched model it doesn't matter which language you're using and we're a bunch of everybody has different language of groovy and whatnot Scala and Java and people use C sharp and and they love the differences between these languages and I want you to focus on the similarities between these languages which is they're all single dispatch stateful object-oriented languages and they have a lot of the same kinds of things in classes some notion of classes inheritance fields or interesting concept methods are more interesting we'll talk about them later they're all garbage

On Hacker News

I personally started with this talk by Rich Hickey (person who made Clojure) [VIDEO] One of the best "why Clojure" talks that I've seen, especially for somebody coming from an OOP perspective, like myself. — raspasov, 2021-06
Rich Hickey's: Are We There Yet may be interesting to any one here: [VIDEO] I found this to be one of the more interesting talks I've watched. Like you (I think) - I love functional languages. But there's a problem I can't really figure out how to articulate where they reach a level where they stop "just working" imo. Maybe it's just me being too dumb. — onlyrealcuzzo, 2026-06
Rich Hickey made a great talk on this in 2009 [VIDEO] An other way to think about it is that the programs we write do not literally simulate entities (users, other domain objects like books, students, professors, classes, etc). Our software simulates the record keeping devices that store /protect information regarding these entities. We are most of the time writing information processing systems,… — joshlemer, 2022-04
If you're going to reference a Rich Hickey take-down of OOP, I think "Are We There Yet?" is the most pertinent: [VIDEO] Of course, Simple Made Easy is excellent too, probably his most influential talk. — simongray, 2022-02
>> I am surprised that there are still no software development platforms where you use one language for all levels and do not have to translate between different ways of representing data and interacting with services. You've spotted a problem that I think many people are blind to. I agree 100%. If you'd like to explore more about Clojure, I highly recommend this talk [VIDEO] — raspasov, 2022-01

Related videos