This high-speed rail project is a warning for the US

Channel:Vox · Length:8:25 · Published:2022-07-29 · Views:1496968

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Vox explainer on why California's high-speed rail project is years late and far over budget, with only a few concrete structures built by 2022. It covers the political, legal and routing challenges behind the delays.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a high-level intro to how US megaprojects get stalled by regulation, litigation and local demands.

It's a Vox video, so high level but not a bad intro — HN, 2023

Transit, cities & urban planning · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

On November 4th, 2008, the people of California voted to fund this: A high-speed rail line. Many countries around the world have had high-speed trains for decades. And this would be the US's attempt to finally catch up. The train would whisk passengers from LA to San Francisco in under 3 hours. And it was all set to open in 2020. Today, it's 2022. And California's high speed rail project is famous. For being a disaster. "...will be the most expensive project in state history..." "...a train that's going to nowhere..." "...train to nowhere..." All that's there today is this one section, still under construction from Bakersfield to Merced. But the failure of this rail line isn't just California's problem. It's an ominous sign for big projects all over the US. We see other advanced economies all around the world that are able to do this. So they can do it. So why can't we? In other words, what is it about the US that made California's high-speed rail line so hard to build? Just to be clear; this was a pretty good idea. A lot of people travel between San Francisco and LA. But the trip takes at least 6 hours by car. It’s less than an hour by plane but that’s not counting time in two of the country’s busiest airports.

On Hacker News

Why even mention wars? We have the money for Hyperloops, Solar Freaking Roadways, Boring Company, and so much more... you know... terrible ideas that clearly won't work, don't even pass a sniff test, but we throw millions or sometimes billions at. I'm totally okay with pushing the bounds of what we can do as humans, and even encourage it. But running on hype is not a sustainable system and arguab… — godelski, 2023-12
Vox basically did exactly this: [VIDEO] tl;dr: US regulation makes it too easy for individuals to sue and stall megaprojects like this into nonstop litigation — culi, 2022-08
you're right that labor is only a part of it. but part of the reason why the CA project saw huge rises in costs is because of project planning and scope increases in the planning -- both of which are politically driven. part of the politically driven issues stem from NIMBY-ism but the other (arguably more heinous) part is how the cities can force the plan to be re-routed [1]. not only do costs ri… — thetli8, 2022-11

Related videos