Software Art Thou: Glenn Vanderburg - Real Software Engineering

Channel:Zendesk · Length:1:07:57 · Published:2018-01-04 · Views:34719

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Glenn Vanderburg asks whether software development can be real engineering, surveying other engineering disciplines and decades of programming experience. He envisions what a software engineering worthy of the name might look like.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it in debates about software engineering rigor, agile, and formal methods.

he explores the question of whether "software engineering" is or can really be engineering. — HN, 2020

Software architecture & design · Software practice, open source & careers

Subtitles (excerpt)

Good evening. I am here to tell you where software engineering went wrong and what we can and should do to fix it and breathe new life into it. I like to keep my goals modest. Uh every few months it seems we have this argument in our field. Uh are we or are we not engineers? Is what we do engineering or isn't it? Sometimes the players, even on the anti-engineering side, are people who had uh really deep fundamental contributions in the early days of software engineering like Tom DeMarco. Um my friend Dave Thomas, one of the co-authors of The Pragmatic Programmer, once wrote this, "Calling what we do engineering doesn't make us engineers, it makes us liars." Now, I don't think Dave would affirm this statement today. He wrote this on the uh extreme programming mailing list about 15 years ago. Um but it's one of the things one of two things that he said around that time. It was about the time when he was involved in writing the Agile Manifesto. Uh it was one of two things he said around that time that really started the the line of thinking in my mind that many years later led to this talk. So, I'm grateful to him for that. These software isn't engineering arguments usually boil down to one of two things.

On Hacker News

You have any stats on that or just the feeling? I find that a lot of flaws are ignored in for example physical structures because they don’t even know. Take construction inspector and walk with him through five buildings. Let me know if he left any building without pointing out any flaws. Doctors, a lot of stuff is „let’s try this and see how if it gets better”. Taking complexity of software and … — ozim, 2026-06
Saw an interesting talk just about this topic [1] The gist of it was: Other engineering disciplines use the techniques you've mentioned because of the the costs, both time and money, associated with getting it wrong. Software engineering lends itself to different methods of development and construction, as the costs associated with getting it wrong or making changes after the fact are much lower.… — modal-soul, 2020-05
This discussion reminds me of a talk given by Glenn Vanderburg ( [VIDEO] ), wherein he explores the question of whether "software engineering" is or can really be engineering. Around the 27 minute mark, he quotes Billy Vaughn Koen, a nuclear engineer, as follows: "The Engineering Method is the use of heuristics to cause the best change in a poorly understood or uncertain situation within the avai… — kmstout, 2020-02
Just wanted to post this video link in this discussion: Glenn Vanderburg - Real Software Engineering [VIDEO] — ozim, 2024-06
Agile is not a methodology or a process, it is literally[1] a set of values and principles which can be summarized by "stop being stupid and trying to reproduce what they do in construction engineering, and start discussing about the why and collaborate, doing things that matter, and being flexible, since after all, we're doing _soft_ware. The set of methodologies and processes that ensued, as we… — charles_f, 2020-04

Related videos