The Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser, Debunked
Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:12:51 · Published:2021-10-30 · Views:720652
Summary
Sabine Hossenfelder explains the delayed choice quantum eraser and argues it does not rewrite the past, as popular accounts claim. She walks through what the experiment actually shows.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as a clear debunking of the retrocausality interpretation of the quantum eraser.
Later Sabine Hossenfelder did a video debunking the proposition that DCQE somehow showed that the past was being rewritten. — HN, 2025
Subtitles (excerpt)
A lot of you have asked me to do a video about the delayed choice quantum eraser, an experiment that supposedly rewrites the past. I haven’t done that simply because there are already lots of videos about it, for example Matt from PBS Space-time, the always amazing Joe Scott, and recently also Don Lincoln from Fermilab. And how many videos do you really need about the same thing if that thing isn’t a kitten in a box. However, having watched all those gentlemen’s videos about quantum erasing, I think they’re all wrong. The quantum eraser isn’t remotely as weird as you think, doesn’t actually erase anything, and certainly doesn’t rewrite the past. And that’s what we’ll talk about today. Let’s start with a puzzle that has nothing to do with quantum mechanics. Peter is forty-six years old and he’s captain of a container ship. He ships goods between two places that are 100 kilometers apart, let’s call them A and B. He starts his round trip at A with the ship only half full. Three-quarters of the way to B he adds more containers to fill the ship, which slows him down by a factor of two. On the return trip, his ship is empty. How old is the captain? If you don’t know the answer, let’s rewind this question to the beginning.
On Hacker News
>The delayed-choice quantum eraser wasn’t carried out experimentally until 1999, so I think it’s a bit misleading to say this is what makes the double-slit experiment (first carried out with matter in 1927) so weird. I think Sabine is right, the weirdest thing in the quantum eraser experiment is still the FTL update of the wavefunction. She has a nice video on delayed-choice quantum eraser: [VIDE… — TxFkdZ, 2026-07
I think Sabine explained this social effect few years ago. I know she's a little controversial, but the key thing in the video (as opposed to all other videos about DSE on the internet) was that you don't get "two clusters" actually. They are both statistical parts of a single [non-]interference pattern. "||" is a lie. I'm not in a physics rebel camp and don't prefer Sabine either, but after that… — wruza, 2025-03
PBS Spacetime did an interesting video on DCQE, but it tripped me up trying to fully understand what was happening: [LINK] ... Later Sabine Hossenfelder did a video debunking the proposition that DCQE somehow showed that the past was being rewritten. [VIDEO] And Matt from PBS Spacetime acknowledged she was right in this respectful comment: > Sabine, this is amazing. You are, as usual, 100% right.… — calny, 2025-02
This is a very interesting, novel take on explaining the delayed choice quantum eraser. I think I can summarize it as follows: The signal photon hits the screen, which is a measurement. The entangled idler's wave function is thereby constrained by that measurement, influencing the probabilities of later detecting it at each of the D1-4 detectors. It's not that the fate/erasing of the idler change… — anotherpaulg, 2025-02
Ok, that's definitely not what OP said. Of course the particle still can interfere with itself after the slit, it's just that when the measurement is made, the pattern of two waves interfering gets much weaker/non-existent. Also, the experiment you are alluding to does not say what you think it says. Perhaps you will be interested on another video from Sabine. [VIDEO] — rafaelero, 2021-12
Related videos
- Randomness is Random - Numberphile · Numberphile · 13:31
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- Quantum Entanglement & Spooky Action at a Distance · Veritasium · 9:15
- Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of the Universe - with David Tong · The Royal Institution · 1:00:17
- The Physics and Philosophy of Time - with Carlo Rovelli · The Royal Institution · 54:54
- The Biggest Ideas in the Universe: Introduction · Sean Carroll · 6:33
- Demystifying the Higgs Boson with Leonard Susskind · Stanford · 1:15:08
- The more general uncertainty principle, regarding Fourier transforms · 3Blue1Brown · 18:06
- Visualization of Quantum Physics (Quantum Mechanics) · udiprod · 14:33
- Particles, Fields and The Future of Physics - A Lecture by Sean Carroll · Fermilab · 1:37:55
- Noether's Theorem and The Symmetries of Reality · PBS Space Time · 13:01
- A Brief History of Quantum Mechanics - with Sean Carroll · The Royal Institution · 56:11
- Bell's Theorem: The Quantum Venn Diagram Paradox · minutephysics · 17:34
- Your Mass is NOT From the Higgs Boson · Veritasium · 6:50
- How the Quantum Eraser Rewrites the Past | Space Time | PBS Digital Studios · PBS Space Time · 14:40
- Entanglement and Complexity: Gravity and Quantum Mechanics · Stanford Institute for Theoretical Physics · 1:14:24