Do Your Buses Get Stuck in Traffic? (The Downs-Thomson Paradox)
Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:6:03 · Published:2020-03-09 · Views:693603
Summary
Not Just Bikes explains the Downs-Thomson paradox using Amsterdam and Toronto: road widening doesn't fix congestion, and buses stuck in traffic make transit slow. It argues for giving transit its own priority infrastructure.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it as a clear introduction to why widening roads fails and why transit-only lanes matter.
NotJustBikes has a good introduction to it — HN, 2022
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
When I'm visiting a new city and I want to know if it has any chance of being great, the most important thing for me is walkability. Walkable neighborhoods are always the best. But the second most important thing is the answer to the question: Do your buses get stuck in traffic? This one question reveals so much about a cities priorities and the way its citizens live. Let me explain. There's a term in urban planning called the Downs-Thomson paradox. "The equilibrium speed of car traffic on a network is determined by "the average door-to-door speed of equivalent journeys "taken by public transport." Uh, yeah, but it basically means that it doesn't matter how many roads you build, car traffic will get worse and worse and worse until it becomes faster to take the bus. Or the metro. Or the tram. You get the idea. And this isn't some academic curiosity either, it's been observed time and time again in cities all over the world. But while it might seem paradoxical at first, it actually makes a lot of sense if you give it some thought. When it comes down to it, there really aren't that many "car people", "bicycle people", "train people", or "unicycle people". The vast majority of people in the world just want to get from point A to point B
On Hacker News
Please, please watch the videos I linked. Especially the Not Just Bikes channel. For example, this one [VIDEO] can quickly explain why a transport system flooded with autonomous cars and poor public transit would make the overall system worse for everyone . There is also another video that talks about microcars for people with disability and reduced mobility: [LINK] No rational person can watch t… — rglullis, 2022-05
To reduce congestion you need to speed up and expand the slowest alternative, public transport. That is the only proven method to reduce congestion. The peak demand for car travel is way beyond the infrastructure which is possible to construct and maintain. More info: [VIDEO] — ViewTrick1002, 2023-11
Correct, The Downs-Thomson paradox [1] is a known issue in urban planning stating basically unless you improve public transportation car congestion will continue to get worse. > the equilibrium speed of car traffic on a road network is determined by the average door-to-door speed of equivalent journeys taken by public transport. NotJustBikes has a good introduction to it [2] [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO] — animal_spirits, 2022-01
The less you invest in public transportation, the more people will drive. The more people that drive, the slower traffic gets. If you just widen the road, all you do is increase the amount of cars that drive. If people can't get to where they are going via public transportation, then they are going to drive instead, increasing congestion. Would recommend watching this video on it: [VIDEO] — animal_spirits, 2022-01
Train fans will always still take the train, and for good reason (they are a better experience in some ways), but the fundamental issue of whether we can address car traffic and congestion is about whether other forms of transit can be faster. [VIDEO] and [LINK] are great overviews — quadrangle, 2021-09
Related videos
- 21. Chaos and Reductionism · Stanford · 1:37:32
- Jaron Lanier – Who is Civilization for? (+ Q&A with Ulrich Kelber) Willy Brandt Lecture 2018 · Bundeskanzler-Willy-Brandt-Stiftung · 1:23:44
- The Miniature Microcars of Amsterdam · Not Just Bikes · 7:58
- How Self-Driving Cars will Destroy Cities (and what to do about it) · Not Just Bikes · 54:37
- The Truth about American Cities - Part 1 - Strong Towns [ST01] · Not Just Bikes · 5:31
- Suburbia is Subsidized: Here's the Math [ST07] · Not Just Bikes · 10:15
- The Houses that Can't be Built in America - The Missing Middle · Not Just Bikes · 8:09
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02
- Why American Cities Are Broke - The Growth Ponzi Scheme [ST03] · Not Just Bikes · 9:39
- The Wrong Way to Set Speed Limits [ST06] · Not Just Bikes · 11:08
- Cities Aren't Loud: Cars Are Loud · Not Just Bikes · 17:08
- Why Canadians Can't Bike in the Winter (but Finnish people can) · Not Just Bikes · 15:13
- How the Dutch got their cycle paths · BicycleDutch · 6:29
- Why Japan Looks the Way it Does: Zoning · Life Where I'm From · 14:34
- The Best Country in the World for Drivers · Not Just Bikes · 15:48