The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013)

Channel:Mladen Mijatov · Length:45:35 · Published:2013-02-08 · Views:103821

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Daniel Stone, a longtime X and Wayland developer, explains at linux.conf.au 2013 why X11's design became untenable and what motivated Wayland. The talk walks through X's history and accumulated cruft.

Why HN recommends it

HN treats it as the definitive, funny and educational answer to why X could not be fixed, and links it in almost every Wayland vs X argument.

incredibly funny and educational talk[1] from 2013 — HN, 2021

Linux & open-source ecosystems · Computer graphics & rendering

Subtitles (excerpt)

okay the first talk for today is by Daniel Stone and it's a real story behind Wayland And x uh Daniel currently works at collabra where he's been working full-time on Wayland for the past year or so having recently overhauled the input subsystem he's also written a couple of Graphics drivers in his time and has recently moved from Melbourne to Finland and more recently the UK so it's nice to welcome him back here so thank you very much for coming to talk to us today Daniel turn this on Brant thank you also hi um yeah as you can probably guess I'm here to talk about uh whand and X um pretty much what they actually are um since my experience has been that no one has any idea um everything you read on the internet about it will be wrong um it's ridiculous although there are the occasional gems which I'd recommend strongly but this I think is pretty much the state of play uh which I'd like to change so ideally I'd like everyone in this room at the end of it even if you don't agree with me that's fine but just stop posting stuff that's blatantly wrong in lwn comments so I'm really bored of it sorry L if you're there's actually a cool bro slide coming up you'll see anyway so why am I qualified to say this more than everyone else on the internet

On Hacker News

> when in fact the lead developers on Wayland are the actual Xorg maintainers. Daniel Stone[0] incredibly funny and educational talk[1] from 2013 could help many critics who missed the 3 decade long ongoing discussion of why X is bad . We've talked about this already in the mid 90ies (when there were no alternatives) and now 8 years after this popular linux.conf.au talk, people still having troub… — DyslexicAtheist, 2021-02
Mandatory video to watch for all X fans: > Daniel Stone ~ The real story behind Wayland and X' [VIDEO] — SXX, 2021-02
I remember finding this video enlightening, a talk on the subject by someone who has worked on both X and Wayland: [VIDEO] — jabirali, 2020-08
Daniel Stone actually did a talk involving much of the same subject matter called "The Real Story behind Wayland and X". I'd recommend that over this article (which was partially written by the same guy). He's actually a really charismatic speaker. [VIDEO] — jmhain, 2013-06
Don't take it from me, Daniel Stone has a whole talk on the motivation for Wayland: [VIDEO] Broadly, the X Server has a bunch of capabilities which are irrelevant. The modern model is really Window <-> Compositor based, and the X Server protocol is just a pointless middle man in that exchange. — nickelpro, 2026-03

Related videos