Tim Minchin - If You Open Your Mind Too Much...

Channel:asingularlifeman · Length:2:21 · Published:2008-02-21 · Views:990745

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short live performance of Tim Minchin's comedic song about skepticism, from his DVD 'So Live'. It argues that open-mindedness shouldn't go so far that your brain falls out.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it as a quick, witty reference whenever someone warns against being so open-minded that you become gullible.

you need to have an open mind, but be careful to not your brain fall off — HN, 2023

Stand-up & sketch comedy · Music performance & songs · Religion, belief & skepticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

um this religious friend of mine uh arguments off an end with him telling me that I'm not very open-minded um and because he's my friend and I respect him I've written him a song it's called if you open your mind too much your brain will fall out which I think is Fu brilliant it's so so clever um unfortunately I didn't come up with it myself I I read that in a book uh so to avoid copyright issues I've given it a subtitle uh which is take my [Music] wife if anyone can show me one example in the history of the world of a single psychic who's been able to prove under reasonable experimental conditions that they are able to read minds and if anyone can show me one example in the history of the world of a single astrologer who's been able to prove under reasonable experimental conditions that they can predict future human events by interpreting Celestial signs and if anyone can show me one example in the history of the world of a single homeopathic practitioner who's been able to prove under reasonable experimental conditions that Solutions made up of infinitely tiny particles of good stuff dissolved repeatedly into relatively huge quantities of of water have a consistently higher medicinal

On Hacker News

All those things are indeed possible, and keeping an open mind is generally positive. That said in the specific case of the formations in Bosnia, reputable geologists have investigated them, and have said that they are well-understood natural formations. The flatirons in Bosnia are no more human structures than the ones in Colorado or Texas. A smart person once said: if you open your mind too muc… — eigenket, 2023-10
In my days of fighting paranormal activities and beliefs (homeopathy, wells witchers, ...) we were usually told that we do not have open minds and do not accept anything outside of our limited science. For one, you need to have an open mind, but be careful to not your brain fall off ( [VIDEO] ) Then, we were very much interested in seeing these unusual things happening. As I mentioned it in a pre… — BrandoElFollito, 2023-08
Tim Minchin had something to say about this ("if you open your mind too much your brains will fall out"): [VIDEO] I doubt I'll change your mind in one post, but: Eminem's music, Eminem's culture is the exact opposite of the entrepreneurial enlightenment culture that breeds success. — duncan_bayne, 2013-11

Related videos