The Dumbest Excuse for Bad Cities

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:12:59 · Published:2023-06-19 · Views:3110660

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes takes on the common excuse that a country is simply too big or spread out for good transit and walkable cities. The video argues that city density and short everyday trips matter, not national size or overall population density.

Why HN recommends it

HN users cite it as the standard rebuttal whenever someone says that America is too big for rail or good urban design.

For a video describing how wrong it is, refer to Not Just Bikes — HN, 2024

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

I make videos about walkable cities and urban mobility. I mostly talk about great cities in Europe, so as you’d expect, I get a lot of excuses and cope, especially from North Americans. Now, I’m not particularly interested in making “debunking” videos. I’d rather show you examples of great cities, and let my experiences speak for themselves. But there’s one lame excuse that is so common, so prevalent, so ubiquitous, that I want to talk about it. And that’s the excuse that My country is “too big” to have trains, bicycle infrastructure, walkable neighbourhoods … or whatever. This is an excellent and well thought-out explanation as to why North American cities are so terrible … Well, that is, until you think about it for more than about 12 seconds. [NJB Intro] Most people are ignorant about urban planning and urban mobility; I certainly was, until about a decade ago, and that’s understandable. I mean, why would you know these things, right? But Americans are uniquely ignorant, because American cities are very poorly designed, and their insular culture and limited international travel opportunities, means that most Americans have never even seen a well-designed city. Though to be fair, Canadians and Australians aren’t very far behind.

On Hacker News

This is irrelevant, though, since the size of the country isn’t what determines where people go. It’s not like trains got less practical when Alaska got admitted to the union. Sprawling, low density, single use zoning, combined with parking minimums, have much more to do with it. Here’s a video that explores the topic if you’re curious [VIDEO] — CalRobert, 2026-01
This argument is just.... wrong. For a video describing how wrong it is, refer to Not Just Bikes: [VIDEO] For text and numbers: Shenzhen urban area is 1,748 km2. Atlanta is 353.04km2. Los Angeles City is 1,299 km2 (yes the metro area is quite larger, but so is Shenzhen's). The average length of a trip in the US is 19.63 km. This is simple basic stuff. There is absolutely nothing that makes Americ… — sofixa, 2024-03
HAH that is one of the most ridiculous excuses... and is also directly refuted: [VIDEO] ^^ "Not Just Bikes" — pierat, 2023-08
The size of Canada really isn’t a valid excuse for Canada’s poor public transit, nor is Canada’s population. Notjustbikes posted a good video rebutting this argument a few days ago: [VIDEO] — jtakkala, 2023-06
> Most American cities are built on a scale designed around human driving. That's absolutely not true. It only became true in the post-war when there was a push for suburban sprawl, lobbied by GM and all the auto industry [0] > it's pretty safe to bet that she doesn't think that she can live where she does without a car. "Where there is a will, there is a way", right? The discussion is not even i… — rglullis, 2025-09

Related videos