Dropping the Bomb: Hiroshima & Nagasaki

Channel:Shaun · Length:2:20:19 · Published:2020-12-11 · Views:3654164

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A very long video essay by Shaun on the decisions and motivations behind the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, with a detailed timeline and argument that they were not militarily necessary.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a thorough, nuanced account of why the bombings happened and what led Japan to surrender.

Here's a thoroughly nuanced analysis of the causes and motivations leading to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki — HN, 2020

World history · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello everyone today we're going to be talking about the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki during the second world war and let's start today by telling a story so at the conclusion to the second world war japan though their military forces had been soundly defeated stubbornly refused to negotiate an end to the conflict their militaristic leaders had committed to total war in defense of the japanese empire and were prepared to mobilize japanese civilians to combat any potential american invasion president harry truman and his advisors were therefore faced with a difficult choice either they could commit to a long and costly invasion of japan which they estimated would kill more than a million people or they could use their secret weapon the world's first nuclear bombs which the united states had recently constructed so in order to shorten the war and avoid the need for an invasion truman decided to drop two bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki two major military and industrial targets demonstrating the extent of the japanese military's desire to keep fighting however even after these bombs were dropped japan's supreme council remained deadlocked with some military leaders still refusing to consider negotiating a peace

On Hacker News

The Japanese Government didn't want an unconditional surrender as it would have meant the Emperor (Who was seen as quasi-divine) would have potentially been tried for war crimes and executed. They didn't care about their citizens, just the Emperor. Fantastic video which explains everything: [VIDEO] — dairylee, 2022-02
> Whereas Japan would’ve continued the war and brought it back to the US mainland eventually. This is simply ahistoric. Japan was on the brink of loss and everyone knew it (including all of Japan's military and political leaders) -- Japan was already suing for peace long before the bombs were dropped. The main sticking point was the conditions of surrender and the Japanese were deluded (partially… — cyphar, 2022-10
Here's a thoroughly nuanced analysis of the causes and motivations leading to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki: [VIDEO] — chagen, 2020-12
> the US only used atomic weapons to end a devastating war inflicted upon it by a ferocious and fanatical adversary This isn't true at all. You don't need to bomb civilian cities to end a war. The Japanese government, specifically the emperor had already indicated they wanted to negotiate. They were already well aware they couldn't win the war. There is far, far more evidence that the U.S. just c… — whoknowsidont, 2025-06
I listened to this >2h essay about the atomic bombing over a year ago. I'm writing mostly from memory, so there might be errors in my summary. I think the argument was that the reason for the atomic bombing was not really a military necessity (fleet admirals Leahy and Nimitz at least seemed to think so). The Japanese were already signaling they were willing to surrender well before the bomb dropp… — ookdatnog, 2023-08

Related videos