Why Isn't Functional Programming the Norm? – Richard Feldman

Channel:Metosin · Length:46:09 · Published:2019-09-30 · Views:1631700

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Richard Feldman argues that functional programming is not the norm largely because of historical accidents, such as C++ popularity, platform exclusivity, marketing spend and network effects, rather than merit. He traces the history of how languages become mainstream.

Why HN recommends it

HN treats it as the standard answer to why FP isn't mainstream and why languages succeed.

This talk by Richard Feldman is an excellent discussion about why Functional Programming is not the norm — HN, 2021

Programming language design · Functional programming

Subtitles (excerpt)

welcome everybody this is why isn't functional programming the norm I'm Richard Feldman so I'm gonna start with the question why is it functional programming the norm I as anyone else wonder this like everyone like ever looked around and be like hey yeah exactly like I spent a lot of time doing object-oriented programming in my career and then eventually came across functional programming I started doing it and doing it more and more and now I've been doing it for several years and at some point I was just like yeah what why isn't this the norm it seems so great like why isn't everybody else doing this so I set out to sort of answer this question and just it's pretty direct they say like why are things the way they are like why are they this way instead of that way and I found out the answer and it turns out the answer is it's complicated there is no one living very simple nice neat tidy answer but in this sort of quest for understanding I ended up learning a lot of things about that sort of explain why things got to be the way that they are and I'm gonna share them with you so because it's complicated gonna break this down into three parts so first gonna talk about language and then paradigm and then finally style so

On Hacker News

This talk by Richard Feldman is an excellent discussion about why Functional Programming is not the norm - [VIDEO] — yewenjie, 2021-09
This is indeed a very interesting question! I’ve also asked myself that time and time again, along the path of slowly discovering what this FP thing is all about over the course of my career. It does look wonderful, it does save you a lot of effort in some cases, where “some” is a vast swathes of computational problems. And its so damn elegant. A lot of examples are thrown around were a bunch of … — seer, 2020-12
Why isn't it more popular? I think Richard Feldman [0] proposed some of the most reasonable theories as to why functional programming isn't the norm. Your language needs to be the platform-exclusive language for a widely used platform, have a killer application for a highly desired application domain, or be backed by a monster war-chest of marketing money to sway opinions. Since Feldman's talk, P… — agentultra, 2025-11
This is a great talk on exactly this topic from a Clojure conference, if you want a long answer. It focuses on the “functional” feature of Clojure but all of it applies to the whole language (and probably any good lisp) IMO. [VIDEO] My brief text answer (focused on Clojure): -python has been around about 20 more years than Clojure -the advantages of Clojure vs python/etc probably aren’t nearly as… — eduction, 2024-01
I felt that some of your questions, as well as the general history of popular programming languages, were well laid out in this talk: [VIDEO] TL;DW: The presenter mentions that Python experienced a slow but consistent growth trend, leading to its current prominence. Other points he highlighted about its success align with much of the sentiment expressed here. — ah27182, 2023-08

Related videos