Ptolemy and Homer (Simpson)

Channel:Santiago Ginnobili · Length:3:49 · Published:2008-07-11 · Views:380019

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short animation reconstructing a planet's looping orbit using Ptolemy's epicycles and deferents, with the epicycles tracing out the face of Homer Simpson. It shows how enough circles can reproduce nearly any shape.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a vivid demonstration that Fourier series and epicycles can fit anything, and as a warning about models with too much wiggle room.

This is my favourite visualisation of this fact — HN, 2016

Recreational & visual math · Information theory & signal processing · Cosmology & astrophysics

On Hacker News

I tl;dr'ed the article (sorry), but I wanted to say one thing about epicycles. They are not wrong and certainly can be used to explain motion, but the problem with them is that you can keep adding epicycles to fit any continuous orbit at all (this actually is because a Fourier series can converge to any continuous periodic function). This is my favourite visualisation of this fact: [VIDEO] — jordigh, 2016-10
I'm only seeing an image, with no explanation, and it took me a while to realise what it was showing; so, in case anyone else is puzzled by it, each image is the sum of the previous one with a new factor (indicated by the "wheels upon wheels"). I think that the reconstruction of Homer Simpson's face (which I think I originally saw thanks to OP ColinWright!) may be a more convincing demonstration … — JadeNB, 2015-10
These guys are one of the reasons I love mathematics. Check this out too: [VIDEO] Edit: Didn't realize that this was also linked to in another thread on the front page as well. — TheMakeA, 2013-11
> This is not an assumption, there is no circular reasoning. Of course it is an assumption. A star moving across the sky is not a proof by any means. > And we observe different parallaxes for different stars, meaning that stars are not all on the same distance from earth. No, we don't measure different parallaxes for different stars. We measure different trajectories for different stars across ou… — codethief, 2022-02
This isn't an elephant but it demonstrates the principle: [VIDEO] Epicycles were originally considered a good idea because it takes exactly two circles to make an ellipse, and Kepler's laws were satisfied by such an ellipse. They were "falsified,", in the two-cycle form, when closer observations revealed that Kepler's laws were not obeyed exactly. At that point, the choice was to either add more … — whatshisface, 2021-10

Related videos