#NoEstimates (Allen Holub)
Channel:Allen Holub · Length:37:45 · Published:2015-07-06 · Views:259243
Summary
Allen Holub's keynote arguing that estimation is harmful, particularly in Agile, and presenting planning approaches based on data and flow instead. It covers the distinction between estimation and data-driven prediction.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended in estimation and sprint debates as a well-reasoned account of where waste is and isn't in agile.
If you want a well-reasoned discussion of where the waste is and isn't, I highly recommend Allen Holub's talk #NoEstimates — HN, 2022
Software practice, open source & careers · Management, leadership & organizations
Subtitles (excerpt)
good morning everyone um my topic today is no estimates and but I what I mean by that is what that hashtag actually says which is to say we need to just stop doing all estimation now is that estimation has no value at all and I am hoping over the course of the next 45 minutes or so I can convince you that that statement is true the main problem with estimates is that estimates are always based on guesswork you're always guessing you can make a claim that estimates are based on observing past Behavior but the fact is is that what you're implementing is something that hasn't been implemented before so any kind of measurement that you've made of something that happened in the past is not going to impact what you're doing now which is to say you're always guessing now the problem with those guesses is that they're also always wrong which is something that we all know but for some reason we behave as if we didn't know that we imagine that the estimates that we come up with have some kind of validity to them even though we know deep down inside that they don't everybody that I every programmer that I know at one point or another has complained about how bosses take their estimates as if they're bolted in concrete and it's because we know that the estimates are bogus but
On Hacker News
One could write a solid critique of sprints and how they help or don't, and where time is wasted, but this article is overzealous and comes off as motivated more by anger than reasoning. If you want a well-reasoned discussion of where the waste is and isn't, I highly recommend Allen Holub's talk #NoEstimates [0]. [0] [VIDEO] — coryfklein, 2022-10
There's an interesting video by Allen Holub that I've seen on the somewhat related topic of ridding software development of estimates (#NoEstimates)[1]. He argues that they're responsible for deadlines that are impossible to meet due to them being based completely on a guess. He then goes on to talk about how we can still get predictive power without giving estimates. I found it extremely interes… — Vinalin, 2019-04
[VIDEO] #NoEstimates Yes, be agile. Yes, measure all the things. But estimation sets everyone up for disappointment. — hal-eisen, 2025-12
Planning doesn't mean estimation though; we all know it's just guesswork, and basing business decisions on guesswork is madness. On top of that it's a lot of wasted time and effort. Milestones and projections is a much more constructive approach, simply tracking the number of tasks in your backlog over time will give you an increasingly correct projection of when the project will be finished. [VI… — codr7, 2023-11
Apparently if you do zero estimating (or just count the amount of stories), it makes ZERO difference when calculating your cumulative-flow diagram. [VIDEO] Money segment is at the 26m15s mark. The wasted effort of trying to estimate stories provides zero business value in this context. — azemetre, 2022-07
Related videos
- Try to Rule Fairly and You'll Be Overthrown · CGP Grey · 18:13
- 🚀 TDD, Where Did It All Go Wrong (Ian Cooper) · DevTernity Conference · 1:03:55
- Bret Victor The Future of Programming · Joey Reid · 32:55
- Velocity NY 2013: Richard Cook, "Resilience In Complex Adaptive Systems" · O'Reilly · 19:09
- Ed Catmull, Pixar: Keep Your Crises Small · Stanford Graduate School of Business · 54:11
- "Uncle" Bob Martin - "The Future of Programming" · Paul Stringer's Mobile Tech · 1:18:21
- Tim Ewald - Clojure: Programming with Hand Tools · ClojureTV · 58:39
- RSA ANIMATE: Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us · Royal Society of Arts · 10:48
- The Only Unbreakable Law · Molly Rocket · 53:25
- Using Python to Code by Voice · Next Day Video · 28:17
- Transforming Code into Beautiful, Idiomatic Python · Next Day Video · 48:51
- Agile is Dead • Pragmatic Dave Thomas • GOTO 2015 · GOTO Conferences · 40:39
- Your Brain Thinks Your Whole Home Is One Room · CGP Grey · 10:58
- Plover: Thought to Text at 240 WPM · Next Day Video · 34:21
- "The Economics of Programming Languages" by Evan Czaplicki (Strange Loop 2023) · Strange Loop Conference · 43:57
- "The Mess We're In" by Joe Armstrong · Strange Loop Conference · 45:50