Doug McLean | Common Misconceptions in Aerodynamics
Channel:Michigan Engineering · Length:48:25 · Published:2013-10-21 · Views:859267
Summary
Retired Boeing Technical Fellow Doug McLean walks through common misconceptions in aerodynamics, drawing on his book Understanding Aerodynamics. He critiques popular explanations of wing lift and rocket thrust and argues for arguing from the real physics.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters point to it as a credible debunking of the popular but wrong explanations of how wings generate lift.
You might get something out of this 2013 talk by former Boeing engineer Doug McLean on misconceptions about lift. — HN, 2021
Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos · Aviation & aerospace engineering
Subtitles (excerpt)
well thank you for Professor Martin for that introduction uh I'll I'll try to live up to it I was going to say that I was uh happy to see so many of you decided to take a chance on a seminar with such an unusual title but then I heard that this is actually a class and that you pretty much have to be here um I'd like to thank the department also for inviting me to come here uh one of the pluses for me for traveling anywhere these days actually believe it or not is getting to ride on an airplane I know for most people air travel is a chore but uh for me the actual airplane Ride part of it is has never gotten old uh yesterday for example uh flying from Seattle to here uh I had a window seat over the wing which I usually don't like because I can't see as much then but it did give me a chance to see again something that I've seen many times and that's the uh sun shadow graph visualization of the shock on the upper surface of the wing I don't know how many of you have seen that but to me it's always an exciting thing to see that uh all of this stuff that I've seen in pressure distributions from the wind tunnel and from cfd uh actually happens in flight and you can actually see it with your own eyes that 737 that I
On Hacker News
As an aside, when you're reading the article and you stumble across the link to a description of how lift works, do yourself a favor and skip it. Instead, check out [VIDEO] . Almost no matter how sophisticated or simple your theory of lift is, it's almost certainly significantly at odds with observed physical phenomenon. — theothermkn, 2019-06
Yeah, the usual explanation of "air goes faster over the top because they have to meet at the end" is BS. Especially the 2nd part. A video about the subject [VIDEO] But the explanation I can come up with is: lift is a force due to low-pressure regions caused by laminar flow over a surface. It is essentially "form drag" (caused not by the profile facing air directly but by the aft part) but the tr… — raverbashing, 2021-06
You might get something out of this 2013 talk by former Boeing engineer Doug McLean on misconceptions about lift. [0] [0] [VIDEO] (watch for 5 minutes to get some idea of his main points, or 35 minutes to watch in full. The link will skip the introduction.) — MaxBarraclough, 2021-06
Doug McLean (Boeing Technical Fellow) has a quite decent talk about the question of intuitive explanations for aerodynamic lift: [VIDEO] Also Philippe Spalart's quote is right on the money: "It's easy to explain how a rocket works, but explaining how a wing works takes a rocket scientist". — zkms, 2020-02
Related videos
- Spinning Levers - How A Transmission Works (1936) · US Auto Industry · 9:40
- Constraints Liberate, Liberties Constrain — Runar Bjarnason · Scala World · 51:39
- What nobody tells you about documentation · PyCon AU · 30:52
- The determinant | Chapter 6, Essence of linear algebra · 3Blue1Brown · 10:03
- Zig: A programming language designed for robustness, optimality, and clarity – Andrew Kelley · Recurse Center · 54:13
- Minuteman III attacks Kwajalein · Eureka · 7:37
- AT&T Archives: Similiarities of Wave Behavior (Bonus Edition) · AT&T Tech Channel · 28:02
- Heat Pumps: the Future of Home Heating · Technology Connections · 35:15
- Children Of The Magenta Line · Mossie Fly · 25:32
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate · AlphaPhoenix · 22:48
- Building a realistic artificial sun (for dark winter days) · DIY Perks · 19:44
- The Speed of Light is NOT About Light · PBS Space Time · 12:46
- Brown; color is weird · Technology Connections · 21:14
- Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light · Veritasium · 19:05
- Richard Feynman - The.Character of Physical Law - Part 1 The Law of Gravitation (full version) · Tinkerin' Thinkers · 56:04