Starlink revisions, Nov 2018

Channel:Mark Handley · Length:6:46 · Published:2018-11-09 · Views:172793

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Mark Handley of UCL looks at how SpaceX's November 2018 revisions to the Starlink constellation affect network behavior. The video visualizes the orbits and routing and estimates latencies, building on his earlier video and research paper.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to Handley's simulations whenever Starlink latency comes up, as the best visualization of orbits and why laser links could beat fiber over long distances.

this guy made an excellent youtube video modeling and visualizing the satellite orbits — HN, 2019

Networking & internet infrastructure · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

on November 8th SpaceX posted revised FCC filings proposing changes to their Starling satellite network I'm going to look briefly at the changes that they've made and see what effects they might have on the hub network functions in the original proposal the first 1,600 satellites were at an altitude of 11 150 kilometers there were 30 orbital planes and 50 satellites near orbital plane the new proposal changes this initial phase considerably in the revised proposal the first phase in satellites at a much lower altitude of 550 kilometers there are fewer orbital planes no 24 but there are more satellites in each orbital plane 66 so the total number of satellites is roughly unchanged okay so let's look at the implications this will have how the network itself will function firstly we can look at is how close the satellites get to each other as they cross in their original proposal the satellites get as close as 40 43 kilometers as they crossed just very close in the new proposal SpaceX have various different options for how they could phase the satellites in neighboring orbital planes and these result in different distances they appear to have chosen a phase offset between the orbital planes of 1324 and this gives a closest closing distance as satellite cross of just

On Hacker News

this guy made an excellent youtube video modeling and visualizing the satellite orbits, the network routing paths across them, and the resulting latencies: [VIDEO] NYC to London on the current internet is 76ms, he shows it across starlink's updated plans as working out to around 46ms. Later in the description he points out a mistake in his own math and says that starlink paths should be 8.7% fast… — cagenut, 2019-05
Mark Handley has done a bunch of videos analysing this on his channel[0]. The TLDR is that there is a lot of room for Starlink to beat existing terrestrial options IF they can get the laser links working on-orbit. This video[1] shows estimates using what was known about proposed configurations in 2018 [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — paranoidrobot, 2021-02
If you want a really great visualization and latency estimates for starlink check out the models and videos this guy came up with: [VIDEO] [LINK] The comment from the FCC about it not accounting for "processing [&] routing" is kindof nonsense on its face, those are not novel problems they're already done by ever other router and switch, including several other satellite networks. — cagenut, 2020-06
The FCC filing has a lot of good technical details on the deployment and frequency usage. Additionally, Mark Handley has a good primer on it. It may kill actual east-west terrestrial traffic due to latency improvements: [VIDEO] North-South will still be terrestrial. — rashomon, 2019-05
Here's some great visualizations of the orbits and an explanation of what it means that the orbits are optimized for the northern hemisphere. (This confused me at first since obviously any orbit has to go just as far south as it does north of the equator.) [VIDEO] — positr0n, 2019-05

Related videos