Tearing Into Tesla's Model 3

Channel:Autoline Network · Length:7:35 · Published:2018-02-02 · Views:762302

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Autoline's John McElroy visits Sandy Munro's shop, where a Tesla Model 3 is being prepared for a teardown benchmarking study. Munro, with deep design and manufacturing experience, points out issues he dislikes about the car's build.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an early expert critique of Model 3 fit, finish and manufacturing quality, and for its note on hard-to-find emergency door releases.

reported really poor fit and finish quality - rattling doors, poorly fitted gaps around the trunk — HN, 2018

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Cars, EVs & motorcycles · Manufacturing & industrial processes

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] I'm here at Monroe and associates with sandy Monroe the CEO of the company which specializes amongst other things in tearing down vehicles and they've got a Tesla Model 3 that they're about to rip apart but they've already found some issues with the car and Sandy one of the things that you pointed out to me was it's almost impossible to open this hood easily easily is this thing is a miserable job and and we've come to the conclusion that these these guys at Tesla are definitely electronics knobs hey don't let anything slide by so to get in here and the reason you need to get in is is basically if you have an accident and you you need to get rid of the power you have to cut this cable twice okay here why twice that would be so it doesn't short out so it can't get better all by itself you know you might cut this and it would short back in and close the circuit and still be still be live so you cut it here and you cut it there and then you don't have any problems so that part's pretty traditional and there's nothing wrong with that but to get to this to get to the point where you can actually open the hood you you have to go over here let me show you with a little light here this little doodad right here this little part of the

On Hacker News

From this video, I learned that it's quite hard to find, and if you're in the back seat, there's no emergency mechanism at all. [VIDEO] — fionaellie, 2021-12
That's consistent with the review by Sandy Munro [1] who reported really poor fit and finish quality - rattling doors, poorly fitted gaps around the trunk, and so on. Computer gamers know the perils of pre-ordering - you've got no recourse if the product has reliability, quality or completeness problems. I hope Tesla enthusiasts who pre-ordered realised the gamble they were taking. [1] [VIDEO] an… — michaelt, 2018-03
> Most of the design tolerances of the Model 3 are already better than any other car in the world. Really? The Model 3's panel gaps are quite well-known among car owners. One example from Munro and Associates: [VIDEO] How can Elon say this with a straight face? — Jasper_, 2018-04
This teardown previously on HN: [VIDEO] Convinced me that Tesla has some major issues in manufacturing. To get into a Model 3 with most of the features people want is closer to 45K, at which point you could get a pretty damn good car from another manufacturer. I'm cheering for Tesla, but come on, fit and finish should be on par with the best, not something I should have to overlook. — influx, 2018-03

Related videos