Linus Torvalds on why desktop Linux sucks

Channel:gentooman · Length:11:06 · Published:2021-03-27 · Views:2235648

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Excerpts from Linus Torvalds's DebConf 14 talk on why desktop Linux struggles. He covers application distribution, distros breaking backwards compatibility, wasted package management effort and how Windows does app distribution better.

Why HN recommends it

Cited constantly in Flatpak, packaging and ABI-compatibility debates as Linus's blunt, insightful take on shipping software for Linux.

Linus Torvalds explains it perfectly — HN, 2023

Linux & open-source ecosystems · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

right uh one of the problems desktop has i mean ignoring all the purely market and getting free installs and making it just so that normal people and by normal people i mean obviously non-technical people will just buy a machine and it just works one of the things that none of the distributions have ever gotten right is application packaging right and now somebody will say hey d package is way improved and much better than rpm and that's not at all what i'm talking about i'm talking about actual application writers that want to make a package of their application for linux and i've seen this firsthand with the other project i've been involved with which is my dialogue application right we make binaries for windows and osx we basically don't make binaries for linux why because making binaries for linux desktop applications is a major [ __ ] pain in the ass right you don't make binaries for linux you make binaries for fedora 19 fedora 20 maybe there's even like rel five from 10 years ago you make binaries for debian state oh actually you don't make banners for debian stable because to be unstable has libraries that are so old that anything that was built in the last century doesn't work right but you might make binaries available for debian whatever

On Hacker News

> You accumulate software yes, but you also accumulate habits and knowledge. Changing OS means discarding all the accumulated knowledge, which 0% of "normal users" want to do. I only ever hear Linux users make this argument. Mac users are confident enough in MacOS UX that they know it’s not a significant barrier to transition. The same is not true of Linux. So many solutions to problems require o… — Gareth321, 2023-07
I watched a great rant by Linus T himself on how distributing code for Linux is a "pain in the arse", but is comparatively easier on Windows and MacOS: [VIDEO] Something I took away from that is that it is Linus himself, personally, that is responsible (in a way) for Docker existing. Docker depends on the stable kernel ABI in order to allow container images to be portable and "just work" stably a… — jiggawatts, 2021-11
I remember a Linus Torvalds video on this exact problem. I found it both blunt at insightful: Linus Torvalds on why desktop Linux sucks : [VIDEO] — KiranRao0, 2021-08
Linus recently said something that left me thinking that Linux on the desktop has much deeper problems that need to be addressed before it's worth even thinking about the fine details of GUI toolkits. [VIDEO] — mumblemumble, 2021-07
I think Linus really hits the nail on the head here. It's the fact that core libs, like glibc, are CONSTANTLY changing their ABI making it damn near impossible to ship a binary from one version of the platform to the next [VIDEO] . You can still run windows 95 apps in windows 10. But running a ubuntu 12.04 binary in ubuntu 21.04? No way. — cogman10, 2021-05

Related videos