Linus Torvalds says GPL v3 violates everything that GPLv2 stood for

Channel:TFiR · Length:9:33 · Published:2014-09-04 · Views:515309

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short TFiR clip of Linus Torvalds explaining why he thinks GPLv3 violates what GPLv2 stood for. He describes why he chose GPLv2 for kernel development and his view of the FSF's approach.

Why HN recommends it

Cited again and again in GPL licensing debates as the primary source for Linus's objections to GPLv3.

Here is an excellent video of Linus talking about why he specifically chose the GPLv2 — HN, 2018

Software practice, open source & careers · Linux & open-source ecosystems · Hacker culture & free software

Subtitles (excerpt)

do you agree that you undermine GPL version 3 and how can we get you to stop what how can we get you to stop oh I hate GPL version 3 I I undermined it on purpose um I actually thought the GPL version 3 extensions were horrible I understand why people would want to do them but I I think it should have been a completely new license um my argument for liking version two and I still think version 2 is a great Li sense um was that I give you source code you give me your changes back we're even right that's that's my take on GPL version 2 right it's that simple and uh version three extended that in ways that I personally am really uncomfortable with uh namely I give you source code uh that means that if you use that source code you can't use it on your device unless you follow my rules and to me that's that's a violation of everything version two stood for and I understand why the FSF did it because I know what the FSF wants but to me it's not the same license at all so I was I was very upset and made it very clear and this was months before uh version 3 was actually published there was discussion about this long before there was an earlier version of version three years before actually where I said no this is not going to fly and uh during that

On Hacker News

Well, I don't think I agree with him and would licence GPL code with the "or later" clause, but he has a very reasonable and convincing argument against it. See this video of him explaining his take on GPLv3 and the "or later" clause at Deb Conf if you are interested: [VIDEO] — jraph, 2021-09
Here is an excellent video of Linus talking about why he specifically chose the GPLv2 and how he felt betrayed when the FSF released GPLv3: [VIDEO] — rkowalick, 2018-01
Keep in mind that Linux doesn’t use the GPL3 and stuck with the GPL2 since the maintainers and Linus Torvalds thought that it was overly restrictive [1]. So at some point the license friction becomes too large to be practical for organizations to use or contribute to. [1] [VIDEO] — knowknow, 2025-12
It's not that simple. In the email you have linked to, he does not support tivoization. He simply says that he finds the term offensive (which is really funny coming from him). Torvalds has also publicly stated that he doesn't think that tivoization benefits users, but it's not his battle to fight. More info on that topic can be found in the linked YT (linked at the precise time he is answering t… — selectnull, 2025-12
It is also GPL 2 - not "GPL 2 or later" so it can't be relicensed to a future version that has additional or different terms. Linus on GPL 3: Linus Torvalds says GPL v3 violates everything that GPLv2 stood for [VIDEO] — shagie, 2024-03

Related videos