Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Students

Channel:CMU Robotics Institute · Length:1:20:48 · Published:2016-04-06 · Views:12932

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Alan Kay visits Carnegie Mellon's School of Computer Science in 2007 for an informal conversation with faculty and students. He discusses the state of CS education and criticizes mainstream computing.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it for Kay's blunt critique of today's computing and standard CS curricula.

Alan Kay, almost impolitely, tears into today's computing while talking at CMU. — HN, 2017

Software architecture & design · Tech pioneers & interviews · Education & learning

Subtitles (excerpt)

introduction but I'll introduce him anyway touring Award winner Alan Kay is here with us today he's coming to visit us for our CS or for HS Workshop tomorrow but we figured while he's here we'll pick his brain a little bit get some ideas of what he thinks about the current state of Cs education and where he might go with cs education um and what we'd like to do is allow you to ask him questions he wants to pick our brains as well so what we kind of think where things are going as well so he may throw some questions back at us as well did you want to make a few opening comments well I think the maybe the he has one I have one but maybe it's not on okay um sure and all I guess with two mics we should have at least two opinions I think this one works um hey for now I'll steal from those will probably be two left okay um well an old friend of mine Neil Postman who's written many interesting books about media when he was a graduate student in the 50s he and a fellow graduate student um found mclen who was just starting to uh write some interesting books about the Ecology of interaction between uh human mental systems and the representation systems that they use and they just being graduate students being the 50s they

On Hacker News

This probably my favorite because it was mostly unscripted Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Students [VIDEO] — blessedonekobo, 2024-03
Funny you should say that. Reminds me of this video[0] where Alan Kay, almost impolitely, tears into today's computing while talking at CMU. [0] [VIDEO] — jstewartmobile, 2017-12
I think you'll like the discussion he had at CMU a few years back, which focused a lot on the technology side of things [VIDEO] — skadamat, 2017-10
I'm glad an insider is thinking about this. But why do I have a feeling that it's written with an idea to make faculty life easy, not necessarily for a great student learning outcome, although that's what they say. Alan Kay (Turing Prize 2004) argues against current standard CS curriculum. [VIDEO] Anyway few unrelated thoughts. --- The undergrad CS courses mostly do not deviate in content.The var… — tomcat27, 2022-05
Alan Kay has part of the answer in this talk [0] where elucidates the errors taken by formal Comp Sci education. He claims there was a battle in the university between testable curriculum centered around Algorithms and builder curriculums based around hardware and distributed systems, and says it's a shame that algorithms won out. [0] Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Stude… — michael_j_ward, 2022-04

Related videos