How The Dutch Economy Shows We Can't Reduce Wealth Inequality With Taxes | Economics Explained

Channel:Economics Explained · Length:16:34 · Published:2020-11-26 · Views:7969072

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An Economics Explained video arguing that the Netherlands shows taxes alone can't reduce wealth inequality. It distinguishes income inequality from wealth inequality and discusses the Gini index.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it to explain the difference between income and wealth inequality, though some pair it with a rebuttal.

This video gives a good explanation about their difference — HN, 2021

Macroeconomics & financial crises · Labor, work & inequality

Subtitles (excerpt)

This is the Netherlands, a picturesque nation filled with windmills, tulip fields and uhh coffee shops. The nation is looked to by many as an extremely forward-thinking place that practices some pretty progressive policies. The nation has an incredibly strong social security system, with universal healthcare, robust retirement pensions, as well as allowances for maternity leave. And These kinds of policies are mirrored in other areas as well, the nation is home to relatively high tax rates, and the protections for employees are very strong almost to the point that people joke it is impossible to be fired in the Netherlands. So this kind of looks like a liberal paradise right? Well, it would if it were not hiding a dirty little secret. This postcard-perfect little nation is according to the world bank the most unequal place on earth, and the extent of the inequality is simply staggering. We have explored south Africa on the channel before, which normally gets this less than desirable title. And if you were to pose this question to google, it’s what you would walk away thinking. But this isn’t the whole story. In terms of wealth inequality in recent years, South Africa has been pretty tame. The Netherlands

On Hacker News

All the same I would much, much, MUCH rather be poor in the Netherlands than the US. Just not having to operate a car would save tons. Also, not sure but this comment may be a reference to: How The Dutch Economy Shows We Can't Reduce Wealth Inequality With Taxes | Economics Explained [VIDEO] and if you watch that it's well worth watching this Dutch economist's rebuttal The Dutch Economy is NOT th… — CalRobert, 2023-02
This is just a PSA for those comparing financial (in)equality between Europe and the USA: income inequality is different from wealth equality. Income inequality might be lower in Europe but apparently wealth inequality is relatively high. This video gives a good explanation about their difference: [VIDEO] — ricc, 2021-01
From How The Dutch Economy Shows We Can't Reduce Wealth Inequality With Taxes : [VIDEO] > The Netherlands skew falsely high on the GINI coefficient because house loans are insured by the state, causing many families to technically be in large debt, beyond the value of their houses. That makes it hard to trust the wealth numbers, e.g. things like "the top 10% of the country owns 60% of the wealth"… — erichocean, 2022-03
Sure, I'm not saying the housing market is in an especially healthy position, just that the Gini index measures the wrong thing. Its increase alarms people, but it just puts you higher on a list with relatively very equal social democracies at the top. They go into some more detail here: [VIDEO] Note that I'm also not arguing that a large Gini index is good, it just measures something very specif… — abelaer, 2021-04

Related videos