Is USB Type-C ACTUALLY Stronger?? Durability Test

Channel:Linus Tech Tips · Length:8:59 · Published:2017-06-06 · Views:2529091

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Linus Tech Tips tests whether USB Type-C connectors are more durable than Micro-B by repeatedly plugging and unplugging them. In the test, Micro-B failed at around 8000 insertions while USB-C kept working.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it whenever someone asks whether USB-C holds up better than micro USB, as a small sample but concrete test.

Linus Tech Tips actually tested 10000 USB-C insertions — HN, 2019

Electronics & circuit design · Consumer devices & gadgets

Subtitles (excerpt)

Maybe the problem is that you guys are the type of people who believe everything you read on the internet because whenever I've ranted, usually frothing at the mouth, about what a terrible connector USB Micro-B is, I have gotten a lot of pushback from the community defending it. You guys point out words you've read like that it's rated to 10,000 insertions and extractions, which is 5,000 more than any of the USB mini ports that preceded it, and that it was specifically redesigned to wear out the cable rather than the device so your fancy $1,000 smartphone doesn't turn into a fancy $1,000 paperweight. But me, I think that Micro-B, especially the USB 3 variant that showed up briefly on Samsung phones, isn't that durable. I think this whole thing is a lie propagated by big USB. I think in the real world Micro-B breaks before it's been inserted 10,000 times, and I am going to blow this thing wide open. Browse privately and securely with TunnelBear, the simple VPN app. Try TunnelBear for free at the link in the video description. Much like the prenatal development of my children, this video has been 9 months in the making. Let's just hope it turns out a little better. So, in order to conduct my test, I asked Samsung to send me their older portable SSD

On Hacker News

This honestly reminds me of this "experiment" in which the conclusion was, if I remember correctly, that USB C becomes loose faster, but continues to work for longer in total: [VIDEO] — FinnKuhn, 2022-01
In this (sample size of 1!) experiment, microUSB failed at 8000 insertions device side. USB C lasted beyond 8000 insertions. [VIDEO] This isn't the first time I've heard someone suggest Lightning is more durable than USB-C, but I've not seen evidence of it. — ccouzens, 2021-11
Did you actually manage to break that tiny wafer or it's more of a theoretical concern? I admit I had the same concern as you, but I'm not a mechanical engineer, and I'm sure a lot of thought was put in the mechanical design of the connector. It seems to me that the outer metal sheet on the connector will prevent a "wrong" angle on the wafer. Linus Tech Tips actually tested 10000 USB-C insertions… — zifutreiua, 2019-10
The cable plug is supposed to fail instead of the socket on the device. Actual testing[1] demonstrates that the microUSB socket on the device does not last the rated 10k cycles and also that the cable lasts longer than the socket on the device. [1] [VIDEO] TL;DW- Repeated insertion and removal led to the socket on the microUSB SSD failing after 8000 cycles, cable was still fine. USB-C still worke… — opencl, 2019-05

Related videos