Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05]

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:18:13 · Published:2021-04-26 · Views:8269497

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes introduces the "stroad", a street-road hybrid common in the US and Canada that fails at both jobs. He contrasts it with Dutch design, where each road has a single purpose, and covers cost, danger and ugliness.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it constantly as the standard introduction to stroads and Strong Towns-style arguments about car-centric design.

This video from the Not Just Bikes channel shows the stark difference between a street and a road — HN, 2021

Transit, cities & urban planning · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

If you live in the US or Canada, then this will certainly look familiar to you. Multiple lanes of car traffic, wide highway-sized lanes, giant signs, traffic lights, parking lots, lots of driveways and side streets with traffic merging in and out, and a place that’s nearly impossible to cross as a pedestrian. There isn’t even a sidewalk here. These are what Strong Towns refers to as stroads, which is a horrible name, and that’s intentional, because these are horrible places. Stroads are a street/road hybrid, and they are dangerous, expensive, and ineffective. I’ll get to those issues in a moment, but first, let’s talk about the difference between a street and a road, according to Strong Towns. This is a road. It is a high-speed connection between two places. Because of the high speeds involved, there are several safety features: the lanes are wide and forgiving, so that vehicles do not bump into each other. The road is as straight as possible, and when curves are necessary, they’re designed to be gentle , making it easy to drive along. The area next to the road, called the clear zone, is free of any obstacles that could be hit, just in case a vehicle runs off of the road. The signs are very large, designed to be read

On Hacker News

Watch his video. Pick 2-3 at random, be a grown up and ignore the tone of voice and the snarkiness, and see what his points are. They're very solid. Try something like this: [LINK] [VIDEO] — oblio, 2025-12
The Not Just Bikes [1,2,3] YouTube channel also has an excellent series of videos based on work from Strong Towns. I link to these videos whenever a friend asks why I chose to leave the United States. :) [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO] [3] [LINK] — benrbray, 2021-07
I agree that the "US is a rural country" thing isn't true, but the way most US cities are built make walking either very inconvenient or outright dangerous. Posting this channel in this sort of thread is basically a meme, but this take on the topic is pretty good: [VIDEO] — snovymgodym, 2023-07
Watch some videos from this channel and you'll be able to see how the US definitely does not do enough in terms of creating safe road infrastructure for all: [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — xputer, 2022-07
I would say in the US, our road design means our speed limits are way too high for safe travel. Speed limits are set high with no attempt at reducing points of conflict. It's a meme at this point, but Not Just Bikes does a great job covering the terrible "stroad". [VIDEO] Most places in the US are filled with wide, multi-lane roads posted for speed limits of 35-45 mph. But those roads will be pac… — dashundchen, 2022-04

Related videos