Copper vs Pex vs SharkBite - Freeze Testing

Channel:Matt Risinger · Length:13:00 · Published:2017-12-15 · Views:1552378

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Builder Matt Risinger freezes water-filled copper and PEX piping capped with SharkBite fittings to see which survives. The video compares how each pipe type handles freezing.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an interesting experiment showing PEX tolerates freezing better than copper.

did a freeze comparison between copper, pex, and sharkbite fittings some time back. It was pretty interesting. — HN, 2019

Everyday physics & science demos · Home, DIY & practical skills

Subtitles (excerpt)

on the build show today we're talking plumbing systems I've got all the major plumbing systems that I've ever used in the 25 years that I've been a builder and we're gonna fill these with water and see if any of these systems are more or less prone to damage with freezing pipes [Music] I've been a builder for over 20 years and I've used all these different plumbing systems on the build show today we're gonna fill these all with water and test the theory that I've heard the theory goes that a copper pipe exposed to the cold outside will split in freezing weather whereas apex pipe will actually expand without breaking is this really true we're gonna test and find out so first of all if you're watching this in the north you're probably snickering right now you can't imagine putting a water line all the way to the outside of the house and that thing not freezing you've either got if you're building new constructions something like this product this is awkward hydrant this is what they call a frost free hose bibbs so now the shutoff is actually way inside the wall cavity or you've got one of these but you've got an inside shut-off somewhere in the house maybe in the basement there's a knob you're gonna turn and you're gonna drain

On Hacker News

Matt Risinger (austin-based homebuilder) did a freeze comparison between copper, pex, and sharkbite fittings some time back. It was pretty interesting. At this point, I'd probably go for PEX-A (compression band) over PEX-B (the crimp style) because of the risk of getting the crimp not completely correct. [VIDEO] — hcoyote, 2019-06
I think the flexible hoses are very common in newer houses. The labor costs are much lower. It also performs well in cold climates. Apparently the technology started in Germany in the 80s so it is well proven. Matt Risinger, a high end home contractor has some great videos on this technology. [LINK] [VIDEO] — pkaye, 2018-03
> A wood stove/fireplace can keep you comfortable but you'll still probably end up with frozen/broken pipes. Primarily a problem with old school copper pipes. Plastic / PEX pipes may be less of an issue: * [VIDEO] * [LINK] — throw0101a, 2022-02

Related videos