Gtk to Qt - a strange journey [linux.conf.au 2014]

Channel:Konstantin Bläsi · Length:46:05 · Published:2014-01-11 · Views:46286

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Dirk Hohndel explains why the Subsurface dive log project migrated from Gtk to Qt, the obstacles encountered, and advice for other applications frustrated with Gtk. It is a linux.conf.au 2014 talk.

Why HN recommends it

Go-to reference in GTK versus Qt debates, valued for a candid account from experienced developers who tried both toolkits.

One of the best discussions on the subject, made by old hackers, but new guys to GUI programming, who tried both — HN, 2014

Software architecture & design · Linux & open-source ecosystems

Subtitles (excerpt)

welcome this is my favorite slot right after lunch everyone is either still at lunch or completely Kos which which means not too many complaints always always a plus and we'll have the late lunch eaters arrive hi Bale good to see you um so my name is DK hle I have been doing open source for about 25 years Linux for about 22 uh and for the past couple of years I've been involved in something completely different which is an end user application I've never done that before it's always been in the system I've done x36 I've done lots of stuff but actually an application that non teis use was was quite the departure um the whole thing of course was not started by me it was the guy here in the background that some of you might know uh who starts weird projects and I'm sure that after Linux took over the operating system market and git took over the distributed Version Control System Market subsurface will take over something um I was here well in kbur but here a year ago presenting on subsurface and and kind of having a a bit of a whiny session and people were complaining to me afterwards that I was complaining a lot and I was mostly complaining about gtk and what a pain in the body part it was to to

On Hacker News

> don't make the mistake of thinking their libraries are meant for others to use I agree. This presentation convinced me: [VIDEO] GTK+ is really just a toolkit for GNOME projects. All other users are secondary. — matheusmoreira, 2021-05
One of the best discussions on the subject, made by old hackers, but new guys to GUI programming, who tried both: [VIDEO] — Sammi, 2014-10
Look at GNOME, notice the giant paddings, title bards see look at the checkboxes,scrollbars etc. Also is not a secret that GNOME developers considered at least touch screens if not tablet when designing the GUI. IMo an informative video on GTK and Qt , it explains what issues you can have with GTK, is about the subsurface application(created by Linus Torwalds that moved to Qt because GTK is bad a… — simion314, 2020-11
Qt has a company behind so is more professional, better documentation, better cross platform support, less bugs. This video [VIDEO] is about the reasons Subsurface (a diving app started by Linus Torvalds) changed from GTK to Qt. Things might have improved from GTK I can't tell and also for simpler GUIs GTK might be enough. — simion314, 2020-03
> [VIDEO] Thank you for posting this, it's nice to see that someone already had most of my feelings. — znpy, 2018-11

Related videos