Why Japan's Conviction Rate is 99% (Actually Explained)

Channel:That Japanese Man Yuta · Length:11:09 · Published:2020-01-28 · Views:81935

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Yuta explains what Japan's 99% conviction rate actually means, noting that prosecutors drop cases unless confidence is very high. He argues that the number is widely misunderstood and cites his sources.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a sourced, nuanced corrective whenever the Japanese justice system's conviction rate is raised.

I've seen this Japanese person explaining the situation informally but thoroughly. — HN, 2020

Law, policing & justice · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] hey guys it's Utah so many people are increasingly interested in Japan's criminal justice system but there's a lot of misconceptions around this especially with Japan's conviction rate which is more than 99% but many people bring this up out of context and as a result many people completely misunderstand this to the point where somebody even say that Japan has a very high arrested conviction rate but this is completely wrong because that's not what a conviction rate means it's actually an indictment to conviction rate which makes a huge difference because in Japan most cases are not indicted in the first place so if you are arrested in Japan you will not be convicted the majority of the time you have a much higher chance of not being convicted than convicted this is because prosecutors won't bring charges unless they are 100 percent sure that they have enough evidence and they think you should be convicted because they don't always think that you should be convicted even if they can let me go through the process so let's say you are arrested in Japan first you will be in police custody for up to 48 hours and then they will hand over your case to prosecutors however if your case is minor and

On Hacker News

You might want to hear what Yuta has to say about this[1]. It's not as black and white, basically. 1: [VIDEO] — kyuudou, 2020-05
This 99% number does not mean what people think it means. The Japanese prosecution system is a pipeline that strongly filters out unlikely-to-be-convicted cases from the very beginning. Long before you are convicted, you might not even be arrested, or your case gets dismissed earlier in the pipeline. Here is a video, with references, from a relatively trustworthy source: [VIDEO] — jdtang13, 2020-03
I'm not Japanese, but I've seen this Japanese person explaining the situation informally but thoroughly. [VIDEO] The premise is, yes 99% percent is a measured rate but also has no utility in a discussion if the other parts of the big picture is ignored. — diegoperini, 2020-02
The high conviction rate seems to be because cases are dropped unless the prosecution's confidence is very high, rather than letting it go to trial. [VIDEO] — jbay808, 2020-02

Related videos