George Carlin - It's A BIG Club & You Ain't In It!

Channel:SkyEcho7 · Length:4:24 · Published:2019-03-14 · Views:2130865

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from George Carlin's 2005 special Life Is Worth Losing, in which he argues that the powerful don't want an educated public capable of critical thinking.

Why HN recommends it

Quoted whenever threads touch on elites, exclusivity and education, with 'it's a big club' as shorthand.

Thoughtful, funny, masterfully delivered. — HN, 2024

Social issues & culture · Stand-up & sketch comedy

Subtitles (excerpt)

not too bright folks not too [ __ ] right but if you talk to one I'm about this if you isolate one time you sit him down rationally you talk to him about the low IQs and the dumb behavior and the bad decisions right away they start talking about education that's the big answer to everything education they simply need more money for education we need more more books more teachers more classrooms more schools we need more testing for the kids he said oh well you know we've tried all of that and the kids still can't pass the test so I don't you worry about that we're gonna lower the passing grades that's what they're doing a lot of these schools now they lower the passing grades some more kids can pass more kids pass the school looks good everybody's happy the IQ of the country slips another two or three points I'm pretty soon all you'll need to get into college is a [ __ ] pencil got a pencil get the [ __ ] in there it's physics then everyone wonders why 17 other countries graduate more scientists and we do education politicians know that word to use it on you politicians have traditionally hidden behind three things the flag the Bible and children No Child Left Behind No Child Left Behind oh really well it wasn't long ago

On Hacker News

One of my favorite clips ever is [VIDEO] It's a big club and you ain't in it! Thoughtful, funny, masterfully delivered. — Ozzie_osman, 2024-04
I'm reminded of the prescient 2005 commentary of George Carlin: "it's a big club and you ain't in it" [1]. Hollywood, in particular, is almost completely nepo baby captured. This is an oft-repeated trend where an industry goes into decline and the children of those who originally succeeded end up dominating it. I think there's a lot of this in politics too, particularly because government jobs (i… — jmyeet, 2026-05
There's a double-whammy here of the Myth of Meritocracy under capitalism and Prosperity Gospel under Protestantism. After the Civil War we compensated slave owners . After the GFC we bailed out the banks. The government giving money to poor people is somehow a moral hazard yet the wealthy not only expect government handouts, they demand them. What's interesting AI is I think many people in tech d… — jmyeet, 2026-03
George Carlin said it best way back in 2005: "[...]THEY’VE GOT YOU BY THE BALLS! They spend billions of dollars every year lobbying, lobbying to get what they want. Well, we know what they want. They want more for themselves and less for everybody else. But I’ll tell you what they don’t want. They don’t want a population of citizens capable of critical thinking. They don’t want well-informed, wel… — mindcrash, 2025-10
It is important to note, especially given the positive view given to the guild system in this article, that it is written on a masonic philosophy page. The freemasons have a long and esoteric history that should be viewed with some skepticism. Secret fraternal orders have a sketchy history. George Carlin has a famous comedy bit where he states "It's a big club and you ain't in it" [1]. My own fee… — zoogeny, 2024-08

Related videos