Richard Dawkins demonstrates the evolution of the eye

Channel:poejavlo · Length:14:09 · Published:2012-05-05 · Views:238763

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An excerpt from Richard Dawkins's lecture on Climbing Mount Improbable demonstrating how a complex eye can evolve through incremental steps. It answers the creationist irreducible complexity argument.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to rebuttal to irreducible complexity, showing that even simple photoreceptors are useful and stages exist in living animals.

Showing quite clearly how incremental beneficial change leads to the development of complex features. — HN, 2023

Evolution & genetics · Religion, belief & skepticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

first the eye Charles Darwin himself said to this day the eye makes me shudder creationists are particularly fond of the eye because they like saying what is the use of half an eye an ie only works they say if every little detail is in place until you've got that the eye won't see anything at all so how can it possibly have evolved and even serious scientists have sometimes queried whether there's been enough time for the evolution of the eye well suppose we start with an ancestor who didn't really have an eye at all but just a single simple sheet of light sensitive cells that's represented by this screen here and there's a television camera behind looking at the screen so that we on the screen on the television screen shall see what this primitive animal would see so this animal with hardly any eye at all will at least be able to tell the difference between light and dark light and dark now the next stage in evolution would be to have a shallow Cup this animal would be able to tell the direction that light is coming from because the a shadow would appear Shadow would appear there and if you can tell the direction a light is coming from then you can tell the direction that a predator is coming from

On Hacker News

Dawkins invalidating the notion that the eye is irreducably complex: [VIDEO] . Showing quite clearly how incremental beneficial change leads to the development of complex features. But it will never matter to creationists: [LINK] . (Don't even bother with that last link.) They'll always just build another straw man. — yarg, 2023-01
Actually the history of the eye has been farily well understood, and the various stages of its evolution can be seen in animals that exist today. Dawkins explains it: [VIDEO] — adrusi, 2016-02
Makes me think of Dawkins' demonstration of eye evolution, where he shows the usefulness of even simple photo-receptor designs: [VIDEO] — gleglegle, 2018-12
Just because something looks "engineered", doesn't mean it is. A perfect example is the eye. An organ of great complexity, but one that is very easily explained by logical evaluation, as well as existing living creatures and fossils: [VIDEO] If you're a software engineer, I hope you understand how procedural systems and algorithms can transform data and functions. Similar processes take place via… — Slackwise, 2013-09

Related videos