Everyone is Wrong About Mexican Coke (Even @johnnyharris)

Channel:Reactions · Length:9:55 · Published:2024-12-11 · Views:1163081

Watch on YouTube

Summary

ACS Reactions investigates why Mexican Coke, supposedly cane sugar sweetened, tested as having glucose and fructose, explaining that sucrose breaks down in acidic soda.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in corn syrup and Coca-Cola threads to show that sugar type barely matters in soda because sucrose inverts into the same sugars.

Fun video about the sucrose in Mexican coke — HN, 2025

Chemistry · Nutrition & diet science

Subtitles (excerpt)

- Mexican Coke is a lie. At least it is according to Johnny Harris who made a video a little while back, in which he found a study that claimed they tested Mexican coke and found zero grams of sucrose in it. I tracked down that study 'cause I was curious and I confirmed that yes, the authors found zero grams of sucrose in a bottle of Mexican Coke. Now cane sugar, which is what Mexican Coke claims to be sweetened with, it is the whole point of Mexican Coke, is just sucrose. High fructose corn syrup, on the other hand is a mixture of fructose and glucose. And the authors found both fructose and glucose in that bottle of Mexican Coke. And the best part of this is I can actually test this myself using Benedict's test. This is Benedict's solution. It's a mixture of these three things and it reacts with carbon yield groups in reducing sugars like glucose and fructose to form copper oxide, which crashes out of solution as a red precipitate. Sucrose doesn't have any carbon yield groups and it's not a reducing sugar. So it does not react with Benedict's solution at all. No copper oxide, no red precipitate. Now as you'd expect, American Coke comes up positive on Benedict's test. Ooh, I already see a color change

On Hacker News

Sucrose is 50% fructose, 50% glucose. HFCS has from 42-55% fructose (there are grades), the rest being glucose (well some 25% of HFCS is water, but simplifying to the nutritive parts) In the body it's literally all the same with minor variations in ratios. Indeed, the revered Mexican coke with cane sugar...the sucrose is broken down to component glucose and fructose in the acidic environment [1],… — llm_nerd, 2025-03
I recently watched an interesting video on the subject of corn syrup. Which led me into the fascinating rabbit hole of sugar chemistry. [VIDEO] If I might summarize. Your body can absorb three types of sugar into the blood, glucose, fructose and galactose. glucose is directly used by cells, the other two have to take a trip through the liver to turn them into glucose. Table sugar is sucrose. a co… — somat, 2025-01
The fructose difference is marginal between normal and Mexican coke. In the acidic medium of a cola, sucrose breaks down to glucose and fructose, just as it does with HFCS. HFCS has a bit more fructose, but not enough to make a paper about fructose suddenly relevant. As to the taste difference, Mexican cola has double the sodium. But even then, most people cannot taste the difference. They think … — llm_nerd, 2025-01
I remember watching a video (something like [VIDEO] , but probably not that exact one) where they did the analysis and determined that Mexican cane-sugar coke contains the exact same proportion of sugars as HFCS coke - and it's because of the chemistry of how the sugars break apart in the presence of acid in the liquid. So in theory an extremely fresh mexican coke might be different, but in pract… — QuercusMax, 2026-08
As far as I know, the HFCS vs Sucrose is unlikely to be the reason for the difference in taste. I'm basing that off this video: [VIDEO] TLDR: carbonic acid breaks down sucrose to glucose/fructose anyway — Mattwmaster58, 2026-01

Related videos