Lone Star Ruby Conference 2010 Real Software Engineering by Glenn Vanderburg
Channel:Confreaks · Length:51:57 · Published:2011-10-24 · Views:30448
Summary
Glenn Vanderburg argues at Lone Star Ruby Conference 2010 that university-style software engineering does not work, and asks what real software engineering would look like. He revisits the waterfall model and what engineering means in other fields.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it for changing minds about whether programmers can be called engineers, and for its take on how waterfall was misread.
I always thought calling programmers engineers was very weird until I watched this great talk — HN, 2020
Python, Ruby & scripting languages · Software practice, open source & careers
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] good morning um I'm Glenn vanderberg I work for info ether with uh Rich Kilmer and Chad Fowler and Bruce Williams who I suspect uh a lot of you know here um and uh I'm here to talk about real software engineering uh this is my I've been at all four of the Lone Star reubi comps and uh really enjoy them so to start off with software engineering doesn't work um at least as it's currently taught in in universities and in training programs at companies if you happen to work for one of the few companies that cares about teaching such things um the techniques that are taught and that are called software engineering uh simply don't work they don't uh reliably control costs they don't reliably produce quality software sometimes even when they're practiced rigorously by people who've been trained to do so they don't produce working software at all and that shouldn't really be surprising to any of us because uh it this seems to be common knowledge among working programmers uh all over this country at least um but while it's not surprising it is odd because in every other field that aspires to the title of an engineering discipline um the term engineering is reserved for practices that work in fact that's as good a capsule definition of
On Hacker News
I always thought calling programmers engineers was very weird until I watched this great talk: Real Software Engineering , Glenn Vanderburg, Lone Star Ruby 2010 [VIDEO] which explains what various kinds of engineers actually do. Not at all dry and boring like it might sound! From the YouTube blurb: Software engineering as it's taught in universities simply doesn't work. It doesn't produce softwar… — yesenadam, 2020-05
I thought calling programmers "engineers" was very odd until I saw this great talk: Real Software Engineering by Glenn Vanderburg Lone Star Ruby Conference 2010 [VIDEO] Software engineering as it's taught in universities simply doesn't work. It doesn't produce software systems of high quality, and it doesn't produce them for low cost. Sometimes, even when practiced rigorously, it doesn't produce … — yesenadam, 2021-05
I first came into contact with this article via [VIDEO] , which is a pretty decent analysis on how people misinterpreted the original concept. — gcandal, 2016-01
Real Software Engineering, by Glenn Vandenburg. Not a perfect talk (especially the conclusions IMO), but a very good exploration of how some of the common beliefs in the field of software "engineering" came to be, and how something resembling actual engineering practice might be beneficial and practical. Link: [VIDEO] Abstract: "Software engineering as it's taught in universities simply doesn't w… — KaeseEs, 2013-04
I would say that this blog post is half right. The half that's not right is glaring. > the pyramids have had 100% up-time with no human maintenance It helps that there is hardly any rain in the desert. Water would foul up the structure in a matter of years. > dependencies are added like seasoning. Hundreds of packages. Thousands of foreign lines of code make their way onto your software routinely… — nayuki, 2025-01
Related videos
- DEF CON 26 - Svea, Suggy, Till - Inside the Fake Science Factory · DEFCONConference · 1:56:08
- Lec 1 | MIT 18.06 Linear Algebra, Spring 2005 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 39:49
- !!Con 2016 - How I Code and Use a Computer at 1,000 WPM!! By Sina Bahram · Confreaks · 13:29
- Hamming, Intro to The Art of Doing Science and Engineering: Learning to Learn (March 28, 1995) · securitylectures · 47:02
- Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:25:34
- Bret Victor The Future of Programming · Joey Reid · 32:55
- 31 Hamming, Learning to Learn: You and Your Research, 6 June 1995 · Hamming on Hamming: Learning to Learn · 44:24
- Sergey Kuryokhin: Lenin was a mushroom / С.Курехин: Ленин был грибом, part 1 · xox · 8:03
- VCF East: Ken Thompson interviewed by Brian Kernighan · Vintage Computer Federation · 1:03:51
- Bret Victor - Media for Thinking the Unthinkable · Colin McDonnell · 39:32
- Bret Victor - The Humane Representation of Thought · Colin McDonnell · 56:22
- How I program C · Eskil Steenberg · 2:11:32
- Bret Victor - Seeing Spaces · Colin McDonnell · 15:11
- 1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology · Stanford · 57:14
- Matt Might - Winning the War on Error Solving the Halting Problem and Curing Cancer · Curry On! · 48:36
- Why Tipping Should Be Banned - Adam Ruins Everything · Dropout · 3:54
- Bret Victor - Drawing Dynamic Visualizations · Colin McDonnell · 35:16
- UNIX: Making Computers Easier To Use -- AT&T Archives film from 1982, Bell Laboratories · AT&T Tech Channel · 23:39
- SmoothLifeL · Tim Hutton · 3:36