Feynman: Knowing versus Understanding

Channel:TehPhysicalist · Length:5:37 · Published:2012-05-17 · Views:2711852

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Richard Feynman on the difference between merely knowing how to reason mathematically and understanding why physical theories work. He discusses holding multiple equivalent ideas and guessing new laws.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a reference in threads on physics theories, models and what real understanding means.

I reference it because I already felt the same in my work on A.I — HN, 2015

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Now another thing that people often say is that for guessing two identical theories two theories here suppose you have two theories A and B which look completely different psychologically different ideas in them and so on but that all the consequences that are computed all the consequences that are computed are exactly the same may say they even agree with experiments they add to them the point is though that the two theories although they sound different at the beginning have all consequences the same. It's easy usually to prove that mathematically by doing a little mathematics ahead of time to show that the logic from this one and this one will always give corresponding consequences. Suppose we have two such theories. How are we going to decide which one is right? No way. Not by science because they both agree with experiment to the same extent. There's no way to distinguish one from the other. So two theories although they may have deeply different ideas behind them may be mathematically identical and they usually people say then in science one should pay one doesn't know how to distinguish them and that's right however for psychological reasons in order to guess new theories these two things are very far from equivalent

On Hacker News

You and the person's comment above you are missing the point. First watch : [LINK] (A.I and physics) are quite related and workable ^I reference the above video not because I watched it and thought (hey that makes sense). I reference it because I already felt the same in my work on A.I and felt (wow someone else gets it) Also : [VIDEO] It's good to keep all sorts of working ideas/knowledge in you… — dframe, 2015-09
The pursuit of knowledge is not a linear path. The reason you benefit from deep learning now is because a few people in the past believed neural networks had a future despite not working as well as other techniques such as SVMs. Discovering knowledge and using the knowledge that works best are very different. Your argument remind me from this lecture from Feynman. Quoting him: "...and every theor… — gloomyday, 2025-03
There is always a tension in Physics between physical proof and observability on the one hand, and having the right idea, the right intuition on the other. Going back to my Einstein example, there were other Physicists who contributed to Relativity (Lorentz, Minkowski, Poincaré, Fitzgerald) but we give Einstein the most credit because he had the right idea, that it's not enough to treat the speed… — RichardCA, 2022-08
This reminds me what Feynman talk to us: [VIDEO] > If you can find any other view of the world which agrees over the entire range where things have already been observed, but disagrees somewhere else, you have made a great discovery. It is very nearly impossible, but not quite, to find any theory which agrees with experiments over the entire range in which all theories have been checked, and yet … — comment_ran, 2020-04
I think you're missing some key points - Good models are important While the traditional computer model is good at explaining behavior, it doesn't help us ask new questions. And no matter how well what we currently know brain fits the traditional computer model, if it can't be used to inspire new questions then we need to explore new models. Feynman explains this better [ [VIDEO] ]. Even though o… — pvillano, 2016-05

Related videos