Energy Vault -BUSTED!
Channel:Thunderf00t · Length:23:52 · Published:2019-08-05 · Views:749179
Summary
A Thunderf00t video debunking Energy Vault, a gravity-based energy storage scheme that stacks concrete blocks with cranes. He argues it is impractical and compares it to pseudoscience.
Why HN recommends it
Used as a critical reference to argue gravity energy storage is impractical, not as a general recommendation.
Several physical and technological factors make Energy Vault completely impractical. — HN, 2021
Renewables, batteries & storage · Scientific method & science communication
Subtitles (excerpt)
we have developed a groundbreaking energy storage technology that will enable a planet powered by renewable resources what this is going to enable a planet that's gonna be completely green and blue our product consists of a collection of custom inexpensive bricks a unique six armed support crane electric motors generators sensors and control software which combined to deliver a 30-plus year life and round trip efficiency of around 90 percent awesome 90% efficiency and control by custom software now I know it's kind of a nitpick at this point but if you know all that about it what am I looking at a cartoon and not say for instance oh I'd note the actual device working as the crane lifts the bricks the energy is stored in the elevation gain building a self-supporting tower which is the charge state when the time comes to discharge the crane simply returns the bricks to their base state our specially engineered control software ensures that each brick is placed in the exact position each time and even takes into account the effects of extreme weather conditions specially engineered control software that can compensate for extreme weather no wonder this thing got over a million hits on court and a ninety something
On Hacker News
[LINK] [VIDEO] [LINK] Softbank invested. What else do you need to know? By contrast, this is not stupid: [LINK] They might still not execute well, but the idea is sound. What is different? They use a single weight, up to thousands of tons. It is suspended in a disused mineshaft, up to a kilometer deep, protected from weather. The one weight just goes up and down, i.e. it has just two moving parts… — ncmncm, 2022-06
Wasn’t Energy Vault debunked as being too impractical? Here: [VIDEO] These guys “solve” the wind and control problem by digging a 300m deep pipe for the weights. — blueblisters, 2021-04
Several physical and technological factors make Energy Vault completely impractical. Dr Philip Mason explains them here: [VIDEO] — sthnblllII, 2021-01
This idea is nuts, just watch [VIDEO] if you don't understand why. Does no one do fundamentals at school anymore, water is around the same density as concrete (~2.4 times smaller) except you can just use a simple pump. The reason they use concrete in these designs is because if they used water people would say it's stupid. That's literally the reason. It's the same for mineshafts. These concepts … — aaron695, 2021-01
I’m not sure this idea is all that they’re marketing it as. Here’s a video discussing the drawbacks [0], the guy doing the video can be kind of abrasive at times but worth watching/skimming as a counterpoint. [0]: [VIDEO] — dimnsionofsound, 2020-09
Related videos
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- James Burke Connections, Ep. 1 "The Trigger Effect" · DRS_Education · 49:22
- Hamming, "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) · securitylectures · 44:02
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Is Most Published Research Wrong? · Veritasium · 12:22
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Václav Smil at Driva Climate Investment Meeting 2019 · Nysnø Klimainvesteringer · 52:10
- Why Heat Pumps are Immensely Important Right Now · Technology Connections · 21:03
- Powers of Ten™ (1977) · Eames Office · 9:01
- Feynman on Scientific Method. · seabala · 9:59
- Michael Moore Presents: Planet of the Humans | A Film by Jeff Gibbs | Full Documentary · Michael Moore · 1:39:57
- Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED · Veritasium · 33:44
- DEF CON 26 - Svea, Suggy, Till - Inside the Fake Science Factory · DEFCONConference · 1:56:08
- I promise this story about microwaves is interesting. · Tom Scott · 12:09
- The LED Traffic Light and the Danger of "But Sometimes!" · Technology Connections · 18:31
- HD Feynman: FUN TO IMAGINE complete (with optional Chinese subtitles) · Christopher Sykes · 1:06:49