Why renewables can’t save the planet | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxDanubia
Channel:TEDx Talks · Length:17:33 · Published:2019-01-04 · Views:5656245
Summary
Michael Shellenberger argues in a TEDx talk that solar and wind need huge amounts of land and mining, and says nuclear power is a better path to protecting both the climate and nature.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters credit it with changing their minds on nuclear power and cite it for the downsides of renewables.
it's what changed my mind and therefore in my opinion the best delivery of the argument I'm aware of. — HN, 2019
Climate policy, solutions & debate · Nuclear power & fusion · Renewables, batteries & storage
Subtitles (excerpt)
Translator: Amanda Chu Reviewer: Peter van de Ven Thank you very much. When I was a boy, my parents would sometimes take me camping in California. We would camp in the beaches, in the forests, in the deserts. Some people think the deserts are empty of life, but my parents taught me to see the wildlife all around us, the hawks, the eagles, the tortoises. One time when we were setting up camp, we found a baby scorpion with its stinger out, and I remember thinking how cool it was that something could be both so cute and also so dangerous. After college, I moved to California, and I started working on a number of environmental campaigns. I got involved in helping to save the state's last ancient redwood forest and blocking a proposed radioactive waste repository set for the desert. Shortly after I turned 30, I decided I wanted to dedicate a significant amount of my life to solving climate change. I was worried that global warming would end up destroying many of the natural environments that people had worked so hard to protect. I thought the technical solutions were pretty straightforward - solar panels on every roof, electric car in the driveway - that the main obstacles were political.
On Hacker News
I recently watched a TED talk which changed my opinion of renewables from "maybe" to "no". Basically he argues that solar and wind are low density energy sources that require significant resources to capture, which all become waste after 25 years. Meanwhile we have nuclear which provides consistent base load, and for very good reasons we have gotten good at containing all the waste/pollution prod… — 0xfaded, 2019-09
> Australia, with it's plentiful sunshine and wide open spaces It's funny, but that sounds an AWFUL lot like the Terra Nullius argument used to disposes Indigenous people of their land. Australia's "wide open spaces" are home to flora and fauna that are unique and worth preserving. The idea we'd want vast swaths of solar destroying the natural environment - one that is unique and wonderful - is o… — mikemotherwell, 2019-05
No energy source [that we've discovered so far] is perfect. All have downsides. Sadly, living in denial of that fact is more popular than ever, but that's a separate topic. Here are a couple TED talks showing the downside of renewable energy - such as the enormous land usage and reliable energy storage needed to compete with nuclear or fossil. Why renewables can’t save the planet [VIDEO] A realit… — kinjba1, 2020-08
Liquid Salt and Thorium are the best wins we have today until we figure out fusion. [VIDEO] Simple facts. — corn13read, 2020-10
Watching the following TED talk, I was surprised to discover that gas compagny such as Total are actually promoting renewable energies because they currently need to be complemented and gas is the main solution used for that purpose. [VIDEO] — nestorD, 2019-04
Related videos
- Mark Blyth - A Brief History of How We Got Here and Why · McMaster Humanities · 1:27:14
- A reality check on renewables - David MacKay · TED-Ed · 18:35
- MIT's Pathway to Fusion Energy (IAP 2017) - Zach Hartwig · MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center · 1:11:39
- Breakthrough in Nuclear Fusion? - Prof. Dennis Whyte · MIT Club of Northern California · 1:38:48
- Václav Smil at Driva Climate Investment Meeting 2019 · Nysnø Klimainvesteringer · 52:10
- Why Heat Pumps are Immensely Important Right Now · Technology Connections · 21:03
- How to green the world's deserts and reverse climate change | Allan Savory · TED · 22:20
- Can YOU Fix Climate Change? · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 15:49
- How close is nuclear fusion power? · Sabine Hossenfelder · 12:49
- Life in Syntropy · Agenda Gotsch · 15:28
- Eating less Meat won't save the Planet. Here's Why · Joseph Everett - WIL · 23:11
- Michael Moore Presents: Planet of the Humans | A Film by Jeff Gibbs | Full Documentary · Michael Moore · 1:39:57
- It’s Time To Break Up With Our Gas Stoves | Climate Town · Climate Town · 21:27
- Gwynne Dyer -- Geopolitics in a Hotter World · The University of British Columbia · 1:31:52
- Ground Source / Geothermal Heat Pumps and Other Info · Technology Connections · 28:04
- A CONSERVATIVE solution to global warming (Part 1) · potholer54 · 21:33