Building Prototypes Dan Gelbart part 18 of 18 Design

Channel:Dan Gelbart · Length:23:23 · Published:2013-02-04 · Views:99498

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The final part of Dan Gelbart's 18-part Building Prototypes series, focused on mechanical design. It opens with a demonstration of stiffness and covers practical design principles for prototype machines.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it, and the whole series, for practical mechanical design insight such as how structures achieve stiffness.

He starts off with a $10 piece of aluminum that took maybe an hour or two to make — HN, 2015

Mechanical & precision engineering · 3D printing, CNC & maker projects

Subtitles (excerpt)

okay so this is a very important demo to understand the difference between strength and stiffness in classical mechanical engineering you are very concerned about strengths for example if you build a bridge you're mainly worried about the strengths if a steel cable you're worried about the strengths an airplane and so on but in instruments and in Machine Tools you are mainly worried about stiffness if you look at a microscope the frame of the microscope probably could support one ton while in actual use it only supports a glass slide but it has to be able to it has to be made so heavy so when you touch the microscope it's completely stiff it doesn't Flex another example if you look at a bed of a lace the bed of a lace is maybe this cast iron could support easily 10 tons but the workpiece in the L is only 10 Kil so it's overdesigned a THX because the stiffness is what determines the dimension not the strength or another good example is something like this this thing doesn't have to take any Force because you just put it here to see if things are square but still it has to be made very very stiff so it doesn't deflect as you do the measurement so so in many many Industries you are concerned with stiffness and not with strength

On Hacker News

Bolting parts together is better because it means you can disassemble it for transport or maintenance. Perhaps surprisingly, this doesn't harm the performance. Lathes, and machine tools in general, are built for extreme stiffness, not extreme strength. Dan Gelbart has a very interesting demonstration showing how a weak structure can still have good stiffness: [VIDEO] The rest of this video series… — mrob, 2019-03
Part 10 [1] of his prototypes series also features incredibly impressive precision. He starts off with a $10 piece of aluminum that took maybe an hour or two to make, and is completely accurate down to nanometers. I worked in a nanotech lab with an electron microscope, and the idea that you could make a mechanical device that could accurately move a few pixels on my screen blew my mind. I thought… — hwillis, 2015-08
it's a somewhat complicated comparison to make, but i think basically the answer is yes there's also a coincidental factor, though; wood is cheap where forests are abundant, and although having abundant natural resources such as arable land and wood doesn't guarantee wealth, exhausting your natural resources through deforestation and desertification virtually guarantees poverty. as for 'cheaper',… — kragen, 2024-05

Related videos