Fixing Apple's Engineering in an Hour

Channel:Linus Tech Tips · Length:16:55 · Published:2020-06-21 · Views:3022055

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Linus Tech Tips water-cools a 2020 MacBook Air, tearing it down and showing the cooling design along the way. The video shows the gap between the CPU lid and die and how little the stock heatsink does.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in Apple thermal-design debates as evidence the Intel-era MacBook cooling was poor.

It's a fairly entertaining video, the things they try but that gap, the entire cooling solution actually, are a little hard to understand. — HN, 2020

Computer architecture & CPUs · Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Consumer devices & gadgets

Subtitles (excerpt)

- There's no denying the MacBook Air 2020 is a pretty sleek little machine. Except for one small flaw, instead of doing what every other laptop manufacturer ever does and put a fan right next to the CPU where the majority of the heat is generated, Apple opted to put the fan over yonder somewhere, leaving the CPU with only about 10 watts of cooling capacity to work with. How much performance did they leave on the table? To find out the answer to that we have collected this bin of cooling apparatus with everything from upside-down air things to water cooling pumps to this tray, which you guys might recognize from our video from several years back, water cooling the original MacBook 2015 by actually submerging it in water. Yes, my friends today is gonna be a lot of fun. And it's brought to you by Ting. Why pay for what you're not going to use? With Ting you only pay for the mobile data that you use and you can learn more at the link in the video description. (upbeat music) To tell if our wacky cooling solutions are doing anything we will first need to establish a performance baseline. Running our MacBook Air, which is a quad-core eight thread CPU with no aides whatsoever. I'm just gonna fire up Intel Power Gadget here and you can also see

On Hacker News

> Preference of thin&light vs upgradeability/cooling. I recently watched something[0] about the Macbook cooling (Intel, at least) and you seem to be right. [0]: [VIDEO] — tentacleuno, 2021-10
Not really, Apple's CPU/GPU teams are very good, hey chaps and chapesses, but their primary advantage comes from the fact that Apple is looking at revenue for the entire device, the SOC is not the product. They can afford a little more cache etc. It's also right to point out that the margin is pretty narrow in A13 and Snapdragon 865 guise. So saying they are year(s) ahead is hyperbole, perhaps 6 … — HacklesRaised, 2020-08
Everything you said is echoed in this LTT video from yesterday[0]. It does appear to be a very poor thermal design, but you can see that most of the issues appear to be from trying to make the user not feel the heat. It feels a bit icky to leave performance on the table like that; since you paid for a CPU and are getting a marginal performance from it. But I remember Jobs giving a talk before abo… — dijit, 2020-06
The newer ones might, but the older ones seem to have the worst thermal solution of just about any modern laptop if that Linus Tech Tips video is to be believed. If I opened my computer that was thermal throttling and found that I would demand a refund. An undersized heatsink that wasn't making proper contact to the die. With a fan that 1. Isn't sucking air in from anywhere. And 2. Isn't blowing … — bjoli, 2020-12
How it compares to normal i9 device. Linus took apart a macbook air and the cooling was so bad that it may be the reason the i9 cooling so badly designed. It may be badly designed on purpose to show that the performance of arm chips in macbooks is comparable to an i9 without cooling [VIDEO] — Dkuku, 2020-11

Related videos