If these pumps ever stop, part of Germany floods.

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:4:19 · Published:2020-11-02 · Views:4137633

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott explains how decades of deep coal mining sank parts of Germany's Ruhr Valley and changed its drainage. Pumps run by Emschergenossenschaft must now work permanently to keep towns and cities from flooding.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a well-known example of infrastructure that must run forever to keep an area habitable.

Geology & earth science · Environment, agriculture & food systems · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

- This is the Ruhr Valley in Germany. And it used to be a mining region. It used to produce huge amounts of anthracite, the sort of coal that you have to dig deep, deep tunnels to reach. Sometimes more than a kilometre down into the ground. But the last deep coal mine here closed at the end of 2018 as the world steadily shifts to renewables. But you can see the legacy of that mining in the landscape, in places like this. Strange hills which are old spoil tips. Dumping sites for everything that was dug up, that wasn't coal. All the earth and rock that was moved out of the way to create the mine shafts. They're steadily being reclaimed. Trees have been planted all over. And several of them now have art like this at the top. I visited one art piece called the Tetrahedron yesterday. The weather was bad and there was fog. And honestly it felt like I was on some sort of alien planet from a sci-fi show. The hill I'm standing on has an amphitheatre as well, although it's a little rundown now. It is very, very difficult to get across the sheer scale of these on camera, the incredible volume of earth and rock that was moved over decades. Don't get me wrong, the Ruhr Valley is still industrial.

On Hacker News

>In the former, you can cause harms that take months or years to fix (and, with enough lobbying, you can make taxpayers foot the bill). I don't think "years" is enough to convey the potential damage unregulated businesses can cause. The time and resources to fix issues can scale well beyond human timescales. This is clearest when environmental damage is involved, whether it be CO2 emissions that … — lordswork, 2022-09
> The Atlantic continental shelf isn't correlated with the Baltic. How do you transmit the power? Do the countries on the Atlantic even want wind power, set up the transmission lines, and pay for it? > Offshore Dunkelflaute is much shorter than on-shore. That reduces the storage requirements a bit, but there is not nearly enough offshore. And offshore is expensive. That's why it's getting harder … — deepsummer, 2026-07
Yeah, I take issue with the idea that carbon offsets alone will magically fix everything. In Toronto, there was a mandate a few years ago for all houses to disconnect downspouts from the sewer system (so that rainwater is absorbed into the ground of the sprawling suburbs instead of overloading the city plumbing system. They've also been building gigantic water reservoirs by the lake in anticipati… — lhorie, 2021-07

Related videos