Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea
Channel:Tom Scott · Length:12:00 · Published:2019-12-09 · Views:5180159
Summary
Tom Scott explains why electronic voting is a bad idea. Elections must be trusted by everyone and attacks on software scale in ways attacks on paper do not, so open source or blockchain fixes do not solve it.
Why HN recommends it
HN treats it as the go-to layperson-friendly argument against e-voting and links it in nearly every voting-technology thread.
Tom Scott still has the best argument against e-voting IMO [1]. — HN, 2020
Security & hacking · Cryptography · US politics & elections
Subtitles (excerpt)
Five years ago, I made a video for a channel called Computerphile about why electronic voting is a bad idea. And I still get emails, occasionally, asking: things must have changed by now, right? There’s this new idea, and maybe it’ll help. Surely electronic voting is just around the corner? No. No, it’s really not. Here is why electronic voting is still a bad idea. Elections have some very unusual requirements. There are two key features that are almost opposed to each other: anonymity and trust. So first, your vote should be completely anonymous. There should be no way that anyone can find out who you voted for, even after everything’s been counted. That way, no-one can bribe you or threaten you to vote a particular way. In the UK, if you mark your ballot in a way that could potentially identify you, so if you sign it, for example, then that ballot is not counted. This is why election officials are worried about people taking selfies with their completed ballots: because you should not be able to prove how you voted afterwards. Otherwise, you can have attacks like “$10 off for blue voters!” or “Entry to this party only for yellow voters!” or “vote red or you’ll regret it.” Votes have to be anonymous.
On Hacker News
Tom Scott provided an excellent explanation of why electronic voting is a terrible idea. Original: [LINK] Follow-up: [VIDEO] — david-gpu, 2025-07
I think the Tom Scott video on electronic voting from years ago remains the most convincing argument to me that it's a bad idea ( [VIDEO] ). To summarize, even assuming you can solve properties like correctness, censorship resistance, privacy and coercion resistance. The fundamental problem with digital is that any exploit of any of these properties you ever have scales really well. Messing with … — space_fountain, 2021-10
Tom Scott made an excellent summary of why electronic voting is a bad idea, and explicitly covers both open source and blockchain as proposed solutions (hint: they don't solve the problems that make e-voting bad) [VIDEO] — Qub3d, 2021-01
Tom Scott still has the best argument against e-voting IMO [1]. Briefly: an election only counts if everybody can believe the results. Making an expert level understanding of CS a requirement to verify your voting system means that Joe Q. Average who doesn't hold a PhD (or maybe even a college degree) has to rely on spooky experts telling him what to believe. If I were in his shoes then I would h… — greenduck, 2020-11
Please explain how a “digital election system” could ever be a sane idea? • Why Electronic Voting is a BAD Idea < [LINK] > • Why Electronic Voting Is Still A Bad Idea < [VIDEO] > — teddyh, 2023-08
Related videos
- 31 Hamming, Learning to Learn: You and Your Research, 6 June 1995 · Hamming on Hamming: Learning to Learn · 44:24
- You Actually Share Your Brain With a Silent Stranger · CGP Grey · 4:57
- LEADERSHIP LAB: The Craft of Writing Effectively · UChicago Social Sciences · 1:21:51
- Your Brain Thinks Your Whole Home Is One Room · CGP Grey · 10:58
- Investigation: How Roblox Is Exploiting Young Game Developers · People Make Games · 22:44
- The First Video Game · Ahoy · 1:00:50
- Superpositions, Sudoku, the Wave Function Collapse algorithm. · Martin Donald · 14:27
- How Bankrupt American Cities Stay Alive - Debt [ST04] · Not Just Bikes · 11:01
- A NEW Trace! The FULL MH370 Story, so Far.. · Mentour Pilot · 56:06
- The medical test paradox, and redesigning Bayes' rule · 3Blue1Brown · 21:13
- The world depends on a collection of strange items. They're not cheap · Veritasium · 18:32
- VidMe or Why Platforms Aren't Your Friends · Folding Ideas · 15:47
- America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has · CGP Grey · 7:15
- Indistinguishable From Magic: Manufacturing Modern Computer Chips · Andor Gafotas · 1:01:20
- Build a Do-It-Yourself Air Purifier for About $40 · Michigan Medicine · 3:39
- Dr. Jason Fung - 'Therapeutic Fasting - Solving the Two-Compartment Problem' · Low Carb Down Under · 36:10
- I Built a COMPUTER in Magic: The Gathering · Because Science · 22:54
- The Only Safe Phone Is One Even the Police Can't Unlock · CGP Grey · 4:38
- The Value of Values with Rich Hickey · InfoQ · 31:43
- I Watched Ancient Apocalypse So You Don't Have To (Part 1) · Miniminuteman · 54:26