Mike Mullane - Normalisation of deviance - IAFF - Part 1

Channel:Stuart Walker · Length:16:35 · Published:2015-08-01 · Views:180227

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Astronaut Mike Mullane explains normalisation of deviance, where teams gradually come to accept violations of their own safety standards. He uses the Challenger shuttle disaster as the main case, drawing on NASA's ignored warnings before the launch. It is the first part of a talk given to a fire-fighters' association.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it whenever a thread involves ignored warnings, shortcuts or routine risk, as the clearest introduction to the concept.

He describes how the Challenger shuttle disaster happened despite internal memos about the problem years prior. — HN, 2018

Management, leadership & organizations · Space exploration & spaceflight · Psychology & human behavior

Subtitles (excerpt)

5 4 3 2 1 liftoff we have lift off when it's my life in the line what type of a team do I want out there holding it in their palm and the answer I came to is I think the identical answer you would come to in The Identical Circle irance when your life is on the line you're going to want a team that's the best holding in their palm and how do teams get to be the best they get there by practicing Fundamentals by doing little things consistently and religiously day in and day out until they become As Natural as breathing you don't even think about them now there's lots of fundamentals out there but there are three that I think have overarching importance to the success and safety of all teams everywhere and those are the three that I want to talk about this morning when I'm involved with any team uh but particularly when there are lethal consequences associated with the team environment as there is as there are with you in firefighting and emergency response just as it is in the space program people die uh when they don't understand the dangers of a normalization of deviants and protect themselves against that and I'm going to talk about that I'll Define that here for you in just a moment I want everybody on the team under the understanding the

On Hacker News

Here is an excellent talk on this subject[0]. It's one of the few presentations I like to watch every once in a while. [0] [VIDEO] — christophilus, 2019-02
The “preventable mistakes” point reminds me of this great video about “normalization of deviance” [from routine/checklists] [VIDEO] — slackerlol, 2022-07
I like the term "normalization of deviance" and would recommand the Mike Mullane's talk on the Challenger disaster [1]. [1]: [VIDEO] — y04nn, 2021-07
Mike Mullane’s “Normalisation of Deviance” talk to a group of firefighters[1] is relevant here. He describes how the Challenger shuttle disaster happened despite internal memos about the problem years prior. The message of the talk is, essentially, that a person or team can get used to ignoring their own standards when under pressure. [1]: [VIDEO] — Sidnicious, 2018-05
> A human breaks the rolling stop rule on a case by case basis and is responsible for the consequences Not really. You can fail to see a pedestrian and cripple them and you won't see a whole lot of consequences for your "accident" (negligence). Breaking rules on a case-by-case basis is also how the normalization of deviance occurs: [VIDEO] If you break rules when you think you don't need to follo… — lamontcg, 2022-02

Related videos