Web 2.0 Expo NY: Clay Shirky (shirky.com) It's Not Information Overload. It's Filter Failure.

Channel:O'Reilly · Length:23:51 · Published:2008-09-20 · Views:55593

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Clay Shirky argues at Web 2.0 Expo NY that the problem online is not information overload but filter failure. He says the real challenge is building better ways to filter and organize what we see.

Why HN recommends it

HN invokes it as a reframing of the information overload problem, often when discussing content filtering, tagging and curation.

Ted has a knack for reframing things in ways that make the arbitrariness of certain historical decisions clear — HN, 2018

Internet culture & memes · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

now I'd like to welcome our next speaker the author of Here Comes everybody uh Brooklyn Town Boy made good clay shery [Applause] than Brooklyn Boy made good that was Biggie Small's bio too maybe I'll ask for a different intro next time um uh fairly speculative talk um it's a theme I've been thinking about for a while and since uh since O'Reilly's the home team I figure I'll try it out on you and see if it makes any sense um and it starts I can't actually see whether yeah there it is it starts with this chart uh you all know this chart this is idc's version of the chart how Varian and Peter Lyman of Berkeley have a version of the chart Google has a version of the chart this is the chart of how fast is the amount of information in the world grow right and no matter who does the chart it always looks like this it's always up and to the right and the rate of increase is always increasing uh we love this chart right this chart makes us feel better this is why I'm not getting anything done I'm suffering from information overload right so this has been right obviously the the the salvation of writer blocked Tech journalists for 15 years when you don't know what to to write you can always go down the hall to your editor and say Hey I want to do a story about

On Hacker News

Ted Nelson's Computers for Cynics probably doesn't contain technical information that's new to any of you, but Ted has a knack for reframing things in ways that make the arbitrariness of certain historical decisions clear: [LINK] On the subject of hypertext, The Web That Wasn't gives a nice history of the idea (for anybody who thinks it starts with TBL -- surprisingly many people!): [LINK] Anothe… — enkiv2, 2018-04
yay for clay and the middle way. he reminds me of uncle ben: "with great power comes great responsibility." he has a similarly level response to the problem of information overload (instead, filter failure): [VIDEO] — pkghost, 2010-09
> At some level we're tacitly acknowledging that the vast ocean of content and complexity we've created is beyond what is desirable or even healthy to effectively evaluate. I don't think there's enough useful and organized information to evaluate. There's no reason for everyone to be stuck in a vast ocean of content labeled with a handful of vague categories, except that that's just the way that … — FullstakBlogger, 2024-08
Tagging is useful for a lot more than just finding old stuff on a topic. It's massively valuable for filtering new stuff and community management. A lot of the problems with the devolution in HN could be resolved by implementing a few common tags like, 'startups', 'programming', 'political', 'current_events', 'design' and then having different thresholds for each tag to reach the front page. IMHO… — malandrew, 2012-01

Related videos