Immigration, World Poverty and Gumballs

Channel:NumbersUSA · Length:6:08 · Published:2010-09-10 · Views:6774489

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Roy Beck's short gumball presentation using World Bank and Census data to argue that letting people immigrate to the US cannot solve world poverty because the numbers are so large. It is made by NumbersUSA, an immigration-restriction advocacy group.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a quick visualization of the scale of global poverty versus immigration capacity, though it is advocacy with a specific viewpoint.

Please, please watch this 6 minute TED-style talk on immigration numbers — HN, 2017

Data visualization & information design · Labor, work & inequality · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

Some people say that mass immigration into the United States can help reduce world poverty. Is that true? Well, no its not and let me show you why. This gumball represents the 1 million legal immigrants that the United States has taken every year on average since 1990. Now who in the world deserves our humanitarian compassion? The World Bank has one measure of the desperately poor of the world. They make less than $2 a day. And how many people make less than $2 a day in the world? We'll start with Africa. In Africa alone there are 650 million people who make less than $2 a day, 650 million. And in India another 890 million people are desperately poor. China adds another 480 million people making less than $2 a day and unfortunately the rest of Asia has a heartbreaking 810 million people who the World Bank says make less than $2 a day. And finally there's 105 million of Latin America's population that are desperately poor. All total the World Bank says that there 3 billion people in the world, 3 billion people who are desperately poor making less than $2 a day. That's 3 thousand gumballs and every year we take a million and suggest that we've somehow made a humanitarian difference. Of course, we don't pull our immigrants from

On Hacker News

You didn't answer the question clearly. It seems your answer obliquely is that you don't want it for yourself, you want it because it'd benefit the immigrants. >They don't bite. I grew up in a class of around 50% children of immigrants. I'm aware that they don't bite. But, it's nice of you to instantly assume that I'm a xenophobic person just because I question your policy ideas on immigration. O… — Banthum, 2017-06
Your points have all been addressed before. See this presentation about the growth in population in 3rd world countries and how immigration is completely incapable of addressing it in any meaningful way -- [VIDEO] The growth rates and population amounts are simply too high for us to effectively solve the problems of population growth with massive, intercontinental migration. You also can't solve … — codexb, 2024-02
He cannot, except some feel-good and virtue signalling slogans. The resources for social support in most developed countries are limited even for their own citizens; taking anyone would quickly overwhelm the system, that's a basic math, even without a napkin. For people, who do not have a good visualisation skills for numbers, there's this video: [VIDEO] The point is, if you want to help the peop… — vetinari, 2018-07
Someone else on HN commented that the poor need to stop reproducing in order to improve equality. At first I found the comment kind of troubling, but the more I think about it the more it seems to make sense. Watching this video kind of backs up the point to a degree, even though the topic is immigration. [VIDEO] Can someone come back with a decent counterargument? I haven't been able to yet. (It… — collyw, 2018-04
No, letting in refugees is 100% political pandering. Explained with gumbals: [VIDEO] Immigration drives innovation, tolerance, advancement of the arts, and fuels small business. But let's stop fooling ourselves that relocating people halfway across the world is solving any sort of crisis. — exabrial, 2017-05

Related videos