The Uncanny Valley Is Wrong

Channel:This Place · Length:18:23 · Published:2020-07-27 · Views:235803

Watch on YouTube

Summary

This Place argues that the uncanny valley is a flawed concept, since 'human likeness' is too broad and the supporting evidence is cherry-picked. It proposes that the creepiness really comes from how animated characters and robots move.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a convincing counterargument to the widely repeated idea of the uncanny valley.

here's an amazing video making a convincing argument that "Uncanny Valley" isn't a thing — HN, 2021

Robotics · Animation & visual effects · Psychology & human behavior

Subtitles (excerpt)

Human likeness almost certainly doesn’t cause a creepy response. The idea that this is a stepping stone to this, is a stepping stone to this, in terms of “human likeness”, and then trying to understand why human likeness has a this strange effect on our emotional reaction. Is kind of like the idea that this is a stepping stone to this, is a stepping stone to this in terms of hair colour and then trying to understand why hair colour has such a strange effect on beauty. There’s more than one thing changing between these images and they’re a bunch of cherry picked examples so why do we think there’s anything going on at all? Peehoo, it’s a logo. If you’re unfamiliar this model: They say with human recreations like robots or animations, when you move from abstract human to realistic human, when you increase the human likeness, there’s a point when it’s close to looking like a human but not quite there where it tends to gets creepy. The common explanation is that our attention is subconsciously drawn to all the subtle ways that it’s off. All the mistakes and differences become glaringly obvious and it creeps us out. We’re constantly looking for social connections, these sort of looks like it should give that

On Hacker News

As a counterpoint, here's an amazing video making a convincing argument that "Uncanny Valley" isn't a thing: [VIDEO] — MikeLumos, 2021-01
Slightly off topic but there is an interesting argument to be made against the existence of 'Uncanny Valley' – [VIDEO] . — Errancer, 2021-11
The uncanny valley is wrong. Or rather, it is a result that appears due to the juxtaposition of robots with different goal criteria. Turns out, when you focus just on the devices which try to replicate both human likeness and emotional relate-ability (drop all the WALLe style cute but abstract ones), it's pretty linear based on how well that goal of emotional affect is achieved. [VIDEO] — kortex, 2021-10

Related videos