How close is nuclear fusion power?

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:12:49 · Published:2021-10-02 · Views:763651

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains how close nuclear fusion really is to break-even, and why headlines about ITER and lab milestones are misleading. She distinguishes plasma gain (Q plasma) from whole-system gain (Q total) and shows the latter is still far below one.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters post it under nearly every fusion breakthrough story as the standard reality check on Q-factor hype.

Mandatory video by Sabine Hossenfelder — HN, 2022

Nuclear power & fusion

Subtitles (excerpt)

Today I want to talk about nuclear fusion. I’ve been struggling with this video for some while. This is because I am really supportive of nuclear fusion, research and development. However, the potential benefits of current research on nuclear fusion have been incorrectly communicated for a long time. Scientists are confusing the public and policy makers in a way that makes their research appear more promising than it really is. And that’s what we’ll talk about today. Before we talk about nuclear fusion, let me tell you a little about our sponsor MagellanTV. MagellanTV is a streaming service for science and nature documentaries. They have more than 3,000 documentaries on science and science-related topics, and they’re adding new ones each week. If you like this video you may for example also like their documentary “The Story Of Energy” in which you learn what energy is, why it is so important for the growth of civilization, and what energy has to do with entropy. You’ll also get to see a nuclear fusion reactor – and all of this in 4K. I have watched quite a few of their documentaries and have found them to be really interesting and well-done. MagellanTV is super easy to use, and runs on pretty much any device. If

On Hacker News

Mandatory video by Sabine Hossenfelder: [VIDEO] So they probably are talking again about Q_plasma, not Q_total . — amai, 2022-12
everyone should watch [VIDEO] to put this into perspective. for some reason, all the news articles are extremely misleading. previous output ratio for this fusion method was something like 70%, now it is 150%. it's a useful improvement, but not a major breakthrough. the whole system still consumes 100x more energy than it produces. 100MJ of energy is needed to power the laser. the laser generates… — supergirl, 2022-12
According to Sabine Hossenfelder, published numbers are frequently mis-stated on purpose. When you look at frequently reported Q Plasma (or plasma efficiency) we are not that far from it being > 1. However, we should look at Q Total (total efficiency), which is still way below < 1, even in the best plans. [VIDEO] For years, I was hoping fusion is close. After watching Sabine's video, I'm not so o… — limaoscarjuliet, 2022-02
It’s true that ITER will not produce net power and that the administrators have misled the public about the difference in Q factors. You can have a reactor which produces more thermal power than you put in to it that is still a net power drain when you factor in the rest of the plant operations to keep it going. All clearly explained in this great video. [VIDEO] There is a real risk that by focus… — TaylorAlexander, 2021-11
Neither. From TFA: "While the latest experiment still required more energy in than it got out, it is the first suspected to reach the crucial stage of ‘ignition’, which allowed considerably more energy to be produced than ever before, and paves the way for ‘break even’, where the energy in is matched by the energy out." Here [1] is an excellent video by Sabine Hossenfelder about why you should no… — lisper, 2021-10

Related videos