Hitting the Sun is HARD

Channel:minutephysics · Length:3:12 · Published:2016-07-19 · Views:2983069

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A three-minute minutephysics video on the orbital mechanics of why crashing into the Sun takes far more energy than leaving the solar system.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it as the quick explanation of why you cannot just throw things into the Sun.

as explained in the following minutephysics video (3 minutes): Hitting the Sun is HARD. — HN, 2023

Fundamental physics · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

Nuclear waste. We’ve got a lot of it, it'll stay dangerous for tens of thousands of years, and we don't really know what to do with it. So why don't we just send it into space and crash it into the sun? Well, first, it's really dangerous to put nuclear waste on a rocket, since rockets have a tendency to occasionally explode while launching, making any nuclear-waste-filled exploding rocket into a really big dirty bomb. But the bigger reason is that it's actually really really hard to *get* to the sun. It might seem like it should be easy, since the sun's gravity is always pulling us towards it. But we're also orbiting really fast sideways around the sun, so that as we fall towards it, we miss it. In order to crash _into_ the sun, you have to slow down so that you're _not_ going sideways really fast. The earth - and everything on it - is moving around the sun at around 30 kilometers per second, so you'd have to accelerate to a speed of 30kilometers per second backwards away from the earth in order to stop moving around the sun and do a sun dive. And you have to slow down all the way – with even a little bit of sideways speed, you'll miss the sun and whip around, not crashing. Ok, so a speed of 30 kilometers per second

On Hacker News

Another explanation[1] that shows how it's not just the cost of escaping Earth gravity (which is high enough already) but the delta-v required to de-orbit. It's easier to throw the garbage out of the solar system than it is to descend into the Sun. [1] [VIDEO] — whoopdedo, 2019-11
That's right, as explained in the following minutephysics video (3 minutes): Hitting the Sun is HARD. [VIDEO] — laserlight, 2023-02
It's apparently pretty hard to hit the Sun: [VIDEO] (Though that video mostly talks about small objects like rockets. Maybe it's a different story for dwarf planets?) That said... Keep in mind that this is about a dwarf planet orbiting the Sun. It's 11 AU out, so twice as far from the Sun as Jupiter is. — EdSchouten, 2021-06
... wait, to throw it into the sun. Okay, nice try there! Everyone on HN should know the Canadarm can't achieve the approx 29 km/s needed to cancel orbital velocity around the sun in the vicinity of Earth. [VIDEO] 'doh, you got a reaction out of me anyhow! — stcredzero, 2019-06

Related videos