Facebook Freebooting - Smarter Every Day 128

Channel:SmarterEveryDay · Length:8:34 · Published:2015-01-19 · Views:905141

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Destin Sandlin of Smarter Every Day explains 'Facebook freebooting', where Facebook users re-upload YouTubers' videos natively and the original creators lose views and revenue. He describes his own attempts to get Facebook to act.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as the first-hand account of video piracy on Facebook whenever the platform's treatment of creators comes up.

— HN, 2015

Internet culture & memes · Tech industry & business models · Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey it's me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day. I want to do something a little bit different today, let's start with a story. Once there was a kingdom where wealth was determined by what sheep you owned. There was a rich man who had many, many sheep. Even his sheep were rich. There was also a peasant family who only had one sheep but they loved her very much. The father of the house wanted her to be the very best sheep she could be, so he spent lots of time with her. The sheep was basically a part of the family and it participated in almost every aspect of their lives. One day a traveller came to town to visit the rich man and they became business partners. That evening they were hungry but the rich man was unwilling to take from his own flock so the traveller pointed out to the peasant sheep. The rich man's cook then took the sheep and cut out the tasty parts. Together the rich man and the traveller enjoyed the feast and their bellies were full. This crushed the family. The father asked the rich man for another sheep but he was ignored. Oh man, that's sad. But it's real. The sheep is your YouTube video, and the rich man is Facebook. The traveller is someone who uploads your

On Hacker News

Did you watch his video where he explains his views himself? I find it pretty convincing: [VIDEO] Interestingly, a lot of people are getting very frustrated with Facebook for other reasons as well. Famously, there's Veritasium's video: [LINK] I can really appreciate what they're feeling. With piracy as we have traditionally known it, at least usually the pirate is not directly profiting from his … — pen2l, 2015-07
It's apparently a bit of a hassle to get it removed at times though. And in most cases far to late for it to really matter: [VIDEO] — wolph, 2019-07
It's absolutely insane that freebooting [1] on Facebook was allowed to persist for so long. It's easy to see the right to monetary remuneration as a method of addressing a massive loophole exploited by Facebook and certain users for years. [1] [VIDEO] — TAForObvReasons, 2018-05
SmarterEveryDay told a story in one of his videos about slow-mo clip of tatoo machine in action being ripped from one of his movies by the large press publisher, Bauer, and reuploaded on Bauer's Facebook page. Then Bauer moved on to claim DMCA on his original uploaded by him on his Facebook page: [VIDEO] — Ralfp, 2016-05
Facebook has a history of fraud in their other services. Veritasium fell victim to FB's scams as a publisher a couple years ago[1]. I know first-hand that Facebook's advertising model is deeply flawed. When I paid to promote my page I gained 80,000 followers in developing countries who didn't care about Veritasium (but I wasn't aware of this at the time). They drove my reach and engagement number… — pdkl95, 2016-01

Related videos