YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else?

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:31:48 · Published:2021-02-15 · Views:9200607

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott examines why YouTubers must declare paid endorsements while TV, film and other media face no such rule, comparing regulations in the UK and US.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as a clear explainer on sponsorship and ad disclosure rules and their inconsistency across media.

Tom Scott has a great video on the inconsistency that online influencers and youtubers have to declare ads/product-placements while traditional media does not. — HN, 2021

Product, marketing & sales · Law, policing & justice · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

Around the world, there are regulations for "influencers", for people with a large audience on platforms like YouTube, or Instagram, or TikTok. Those regulations make sure that if someone is paid to endorse a product, they have to declare that payment to the people watching. But... why does no-one on TV, or film, or anywhere else have to do that? What's up world? It's your boy, TomReacts. And today's lazy reaction video is sponsored by Disguised Gambling Game. Level up in an endless series of battles designed to create an addiction loop! Then when the dopamine hits go away, bring them back by paying money for loot crates! They look and feel like a random slot machine, but in reality, they're rigged so you win just enough to keep you feeding more and more money desperately into the game until it drains all your bank accounts and credit cards. It won't work on everyone, but it'll work on a few people, and that's how they make a profit. It's like a casino, but without any regulation, and children can play too! I am morally complicit in this! What counts as advertising? That's not a rhetorical question, it is genuinely up for debate. Take this song from nearly a century ago: ♪ Does the Spearmint lose its flavour on the bedpost overnight? ♪

On Hacker News

There's only so much money you can make off of banner ads and at a certain point native advertisements are way more lucrative. I wonder how they get around disclosure requirements but I guess it's probably because the articles are never directly funded but there's some other form of compensation in the backend. Tom Scott made an interesting video about internet advertising regulations a while bac… — xmprt, 2024-04
> not enough context, maybe > Probably some corporate compliance drones and underfunded government stooges. Youtube alone has 720,000 hours of fresh video content per day Tiktok must have less number of hours but more Videos per day. Add Instagram, facebook, Twitter and it's impossible for anyone to verify this manually so in the end how is the platform supposed to decide what to show and what no… — cowl, 2023-04
FWIW the UK also has fairly strict laws about this (possibly stricter than Germany). Tom Scott once did a good video about this: [VIDEO] German streamers also ran into a separate issue with German broadcasting regulations when they tried to run a 24/7 streaming format. Turns out you need a broadcasting license for continuous scheduled programming like that. — hnbad, 2023-03
A bit unrelated, but if you want a overview of sponsorships in different media platforms across different countries (mostly Britain and US though), I suggest watching Tom Scott's excellent video: [VIDEO] . (Note that the video is ~30 minutes long. It's unfortunately that complicated, even when only talking rules mainly in two countries.) — zinekeller, 2021-09
On the subject, Tom Scott has a great video on the inconsistency that online influencers and youtubers have to declare ads/product-placements while traditional media does not. [VIDEO] — Pxtl, 2021-09

Related videos