Music Theory and White Supremacy

Channel:Adam Neely · Length:44:01 · Published:2020-09-07 · Views:3237024

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Adam Neely examines Phil Ewell's paper arguing Western music theory is framed by a white racial perspective. He covers North Indian theory, alternative frameworks, Schenker and responses to the paper.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as the canonical video on how music theory is really the theory of one Western tradition, with the raga example.

The canonical video on the subject — HN, 2024

Social issues & culture · Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

so if you're online and you see the phrase music theory try replacing it with the phrase the harmonic style of 18th century european musicians and see if it still makes sense in context here is an article that claims to explain the genius of lady gaga using the harmonic style of 18th century european musicians the article then goes on to highlight her song bad romance's use of the ray's leading tone in a minor key which was very popular in 18th century europe very cool this is a class that you can take all about the harmonic style of 18th century european musicians and the way that you can tell is by looking at the course catalog which has a lot of tonal harmony in it which was very popular in 18th century europe this is a thread on the electronic music producer dead mouse's subreddit which asks does joel use the harmonic style of 18th century european musicians well no he doesn't use the same vocabulary that mozart did and he is very clear in interviews that he uses a different skill set do you self-identify as a tech guy or as a musical artist at this point i think i'm more tech than you know mozart or whatever that what about need help understanding how this progression fits in with the harmonic style of 18th

On Hacker News

The canonical video on the subject: [VIDEO] Some people will naively say "All music has pentatonic! Universal!" but ignore vital cultural context. One example in the video is ragas: they can look a lot like Western scales and modes, but they have a time and context. Western music also has a time and context, but it doesn't stand out as much to us unless someone goes full ham breaking that context… — Kye, 2024-07
I grew up in a family of classical musicians, got a degree in music, and was briefly a professional classical musician myself. So my advice may be very out of touch with the experience of someone learning for the first time, but my experiences learning beyond European classical music theory left me feeling insulted. The basics of music theory are presented as though they are the foundations upon … — shirleyquirk, 2023-03
There's a very good video on the way too narrow view many people in the west have of music. [VIDEO] I know the title will set people off in a place like this, but it's not a 2014 Tumblr-level "kill white people" style analysis. Totally worth the time. — Kye, 2021-03
> pop music lacks musicality, most of what they listed were to do with sonic tricks that are not really tied to musicality or musicianship This is a paradox, though. You’re saying that one of the most popular types of music “lacks musicality”. The only way that can be true is if you start with a narrow and arbitrary definition of what “musicality” is. If you examine the history of ideas of what i… — tobr, 2020-09
I don’t think you can really throw music theory out because so much of it is inate to humans hearing and culture, and it’s largely a formalization of such. However, the rub is that what most people consider music theory is western classical theory. There’s a lot of different music theories around the world , with different scales, structures etc… Here’s a video you might find interesting of a mic… — dagmx, 2022-10

Related videos