The Witness - A Great Game That You Shouldn't Play
Channel:Joseph Anderson · Length:41:02 · Published:2016-03-31 · Views:6220013
Summary
Joseph Anderson's long critique of Jonathan Blow's puzzle game The Witness, covering its gameplay, its hundreds of puzzles and its philosophical pretensions. He argues it is a great game that he nonetheless advises against playing.
Why HN recommends it
HN uses it mainly as a critical review of the game, saying it captures a lack of respect for the player, though one commenter suggests watching it after finishing.
I think this was a fair critique of the Witness and why it lacks respect for the player — HN, 2022
Game design · Gaming culture & analysis
Subtitles (excerpt)
The Witness is all about perspective. It's the only conclusion that I can think of that pulls it all together. It's a game about experiencing things multiple times and seeing something different each time. I love this game. I also hated it. I think you should play it. I also think you shouldn't play it. I'm not trying to be coy or difficult, this is simply how conflicted I am on the game and after failing to write the script several times, I've resolved that the only way I can get through it is to be honest to the point of being contradictory. This video will spoil everything about this game. Reviews have purposefully omitted several important features; I will not be doing that. If you have the slightest intention of playing this game, whether it's a week from now or a year when it goes on sale, then do not watch this video. This is not a review, and this game is best played blind. I already had two questions I wanted answered before I started playing The Witness: the first was, "Why is it called 'The Witness?' " The second was, "How is the game going to keep line puzzles interesting for its entire duration?" After playing the game for 50 hours I can answer this question here with, And I can only propose a guess for the first one
On Hacker News
When you're done playing, I recommend watching this video: [VIDEO] Games are part art, what's more to understand? There's some fun image out there I can't exactly recall, but it's basically of an interview with some game devs, and one of them saying something like "We wanted to have a pot with flowers on the table here, and when you come back to this room later, the color of the flowers changes. … — Jach, 2022-02
I loved the interpretation videos out there on Witness. It's like an experimental style Alan Watts video. [LINK] [VIDEO] — passion__desire, 2022-04
How do you compare it to the Portal games or the Talos principle? I find those superior in puzzle mechanics, sense of achievement and playing dynamics. They can be challenging but you never feel aimlessly going around without a purpose like the Witness. There is good review of the game on youtube by the title "The Witness - A Great Game That You Shouldn't Play", it covers a lot and resonates well… — dsego, 2025-12
> "attempting to impress by affecting greater importance, talent, culture, etc., than is actually possessed" I think the critiques in this video [0] sum up my main feelings about the game. The puzzles are fantastic. The <spoiler> puzzles are fantastic. The movement, environment, graphics, etc are all fantastic. But, the "story" and "message" of the game can be interpreted in many ways. It is art … — gravypod, 2022-06
Had high expectations for this game, anticipating with great excitement. I loved Braid, was following all the blog posts and videos with great admiration. And the game wasn't that bad, it was interesting for a while, but also frustrating. Talos on the other hand was a revelation, a thoroughly fun and enjoyable experience, very similar to Portal games. I think this was a fair critique of the Witne… — dsego, 2022-04
Related videos
- Clojure for Java Programmers Part 1 - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:48:12
- Invited Talk - Guy Steele · ClojureTV · 1:07:22
- Failing to Fail: The Spiderweb Software Way · GDC Festival of Gaming · 59:47
- Richard Feynman talks about light · sdfhsfh · 5:55
- Sketchpad, by Dr. Ivan Sutherland with comments by Alan Kay · David Carroll · 3:47
- In Search Of A Flat Earth · Folding Ideas · 1:16:16
- Juice it or lose it - a talk by Martin Jonasson & Petri Purho · grapefrukt · 15:38
- This Is Phil Fish · Innuendo Studios · 19:05
- Jan Willem Nijman - Vlambeer - "The art of screenshake" at INDIGO Classes 2013 · Dutch Game Garden · 44:09
- Preventing the Collapse of Civilization / Jonathan Blow (Thekla, Inc) · DevGAMM · 1:02:41
- The Engoodening of No Man's Sky · Internet Historian · 53:51
- Contrepreneurs: The Mikkelsen Twins · Folding Ideas · 1:15:37
- This is Financial Advice · Folding Ideas · 2:31:43
- Why Are You So Angry? Part 1: A Short History of Anita Sarkeesian · Innuendo Studios · 9:35
- Exploring the Tech and Design of Noita · GDC Festival of Gaming · 31:00
- Roblox Pressured Us to Delete Our Video. So We Dug Deeper. · People Make Games · 35:21