The Witness - A Great Game That You Shouldn't Play

Channel:Joseph Anderson · Length:41:02 · Published:2016-03-31 · Views:6220013

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Joseph Anderson's long critique of Jonathan Blow's puzzle game The Witness, covering its gameplay, its hundreds of puzzles and its philosophical pretensions. He argues it is a great game that he nonetheless advises against playing.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it mainly as a critical review of the game, saying it captures a lack of respect for the player, though one commenter suggests watching it after finishing.

I think this was a fair critique of the Witness and why it lacks respect for the player — HN, 2022

Game design · Gaming culture & analysis

Subtitles (excerpt)

The Witness is all about perspective. It's the only conclusion that I can think of that pulls it all together. It's a game about experiencing things multiple times and seeing something different each time. I love this game. I also hated it. I think you should play it. I also think you shouldn't play it. I'm not trying to be coy or difficult, this is simply how conflicted I am on the game and after failing to write the script several times, I've resolved that the only way I can get through it is to be honest to the point of being contradictory. This video will spoil everything about this game. Reviews have purposefully omitted several important features; I will not be doing that. If you have the slightest intention of playing this game, whether it's a week from now or a year when it goes on sale, then do not watch this video. This is not a review, and this game is best played blind. I already had two questions I wanted answered before I started playing The Witness: the first was, "Why is it called 'The Witness?' " The second was, "How is the game going to keep line puzzles interesting for its entire duration?" After playing the game for 50 hours I can answer this question here with, And I can only propose a guess for the first one

On Hacker News

When you're done playing, I recommend watching this video: [VIDEO] Games are part art, what's more to understand? There's some fun image out there I can't exactly recall, but it's basically of an interview with some game devs, and one of them saying something like "We wanted to have a pot with flowers on the table here, and when you come back to this room later, the color of the flowers changes. … — Jach, 2022-02
I loved the interpretation videos out there on Witness. It's like an experimental style Alan Watts video. [LINK] [VIDEO] — passion__desire, 2022-04
How do you compare it to the Portal games or the Talos principle? I find those superior in puzzle mechanics, sense of achievement and playing dynamics. They can be challenging but you never feel aimlessly going around without a purpose like the Witness. There is good review of the game on youtube by the title "The Witness - A Great Game That You Shouldn't Play", it covers a lot and resonates well… — dsego, 2025-12
> "attempting to impress by affecting greater importance, talent, culture, etc., than is actually possessed" I think the critiques in this video [0] sum up my main feelings about the game. The puzzles are fantastic. The <spoiler> puzzles are fantastic. The movement, environment, graphics, etc are all fantastic. But, the "story" and "message" of the game can be interpreted in many ways. It is art … — gravypod, 2022-06
Had high expectations for this game, anticipating with great excitement. I loved Braid, was following all the blog posts and videos with great admiration. And the game wasn't that bad, it was interesting for a while, but also frustrating. Talos on the other hand was a revelation, a thoroughly fun and enjoyable experience, very similar to Portal games. I think this was a fair critique of the Witne… — dsego, 2022-04

Related videos