Peter Singer - ordinary people are evil

Channel:Jeffrey Kaplan · Length:33:51 · Published:2020-01-23 · Views:5870444

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Philosopher Jeffrey Kaplan summarizes Peter Singer's 1972 essay 'Famine, Affluence, and Morality', arguing that failing to give to save lives is morally comparable to letting a child drown. It is a short lecture on the argument's structure.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as the best short exposition of Singer's argument for a duty to give.

I think the video is the best short exposition but you could try reading the paper the video is about — HN, 2026

University lectures & courses · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

It's a very radical conclusion. And the problem is it's very hard to see what's wrong with the argument. The argument seems like a good one. And it has seemed that way to everyone who read this paper since 1972. Today we're talking about an absolutely revolutionary paper published by a philosopher named Peter Singer in 1972. The name of the paper is famine, affluence and morality. And the basic idea is that the moral stance that you have, your attitude towards your moral obligations um and the things that you may or may not do in your life and the attitude that all of your friends and all of your relatives have. The general moral outlook that everyone around you has is deeply and profoundly wrong. And the crazy thing about this paper is that on the surface at least it's very persuasive he seems Singer seems to be right. It seems to be once you go through the argument that he lays out, it seems to be that we need to completely rework our entire society and more specifically, forget about society for a minute, you need to completely rework your life if your life is going to be a moral one. And sort of what makes the paper so radical is that I can say all of these things that the thesis of the paper is that you need to completely rework your life without

On Hacker News

> If I gave $500 to kids cancer research every year for 5 years, and then I don't give this year, do I have blood on my hands every time a kid dies of cancer from now on? And if you didn't ever donate, you don't? > How does this work? Okay, since the topic at hand is steelmanning, that is, replying to the strongest possible argument, let's practice that. I invite you to watch this video, which is… — nextaccountic, 2026-07
> I don't see why you should feel guilt. You should feel guilty because you can do something about other people's suffering, instead of being a greedy hoarder who has far more than he could possibly use in multiple lifetimes while other people starve and live miserable lives due to the system you benefit from. I think Peter Singer makes the argument very well [1] but many others in the history of… — guerrilla, 2025-03
You’re being facetious, but Peter Singer made this exact point about “ordinary people being evil” in a famous philosophy essay in 1972. [VIDEO] — aamargulies, 2024-12
Peter Singer's Famine Affluence & Morality (1972) argued similarly, that we allow human suffering & don't do anything, even though we could. And he said that makes us provably evil. Recent submission, a video on Singer's paper: [LINK] [VIDEO] — rektide, 2023-05

Related videos